Creepypasta BF Scenarios!

Jealousy

Jeff the Killer

I've spent a lot of time with my darling (Y/n). Too much time, I'm often told. But I don't care what anyone has to say. It surprises me how little effort it took to get the crimes and murders out of their head but that just proves how much I've been improving. My charisma and charm know no bounds it seems and I won't be letting this goldmine escape. Just the simple fact of being a savior absolves all the shit I've done. The shit they've seen me do.

The entire academy readily available for me to kill? How absolutely splendid! It's been a while since I've killed anybody. I'll have to figure some things out before I can enact my plan.

You're mine (Y/n). Our fates were sealed that night.

***

Jeff had been acting out lately and some of his behavior was beginning to bug you. He was invading your personal time and he had visited you at school one too many times. You'd made extra efforts to stay at school, spending more time with a new study group. There was a guy, in particular, you'd grown to fancy. His name was Sergio and you had a date with him that evening.

Sergio was sweeter than anyone you'd ever met. He didn't poke fun at you with the exception of harmless teasing. He opened doors for you, complimented your smile, and brought snacks to share often. He was almost perfect. Something felt off. Not about Sergio per se but something felt off. There was this itch and fear that someone was watching.

***

Jeff hid in the shadows, flipping his knife around while he watched (Y/n). Despite the smile on his face, he was fuming. He'd gained their trust, stood by their side, and even kissed them! What else could possibly be needed? (Y/n) was his and after finding such a gold mine, he wasn't planning on letting this one go. He was finally in. He was finally trusted.

Then why the hell was (Y/n) going out on a date with someone else?!

This needed to be corrected. Jeff's mind raced, trying to formulate the perfect idea. Then it hit him. He needed to eliminate the competition.

He spent the day following Sergio and (Y/n) around, feeling his blood boil while the two laughed and joked around. Things would be fine. He would gain the affection of his beloved once again. Things were calm until he saw them link arms. Jeff wanted to jump out and strangle the man right then and there but patience was a virtue and the satisfaction he'd get from murdering him later would be more rewarding.

The more time passed the less impatient he became. Oh, how he wanted to watch the life drain from Sergio's eyes. Which would happen a lot sooner now that he had dropped off (Y/n) home. Jeff followed the handsome lad home, flipping his knife as he followed several steps behind him. It was late into the evening and both the town and campus were pretty empty. Jeff could've been caught right now and nothing would deter his plans. He'd simply kill whoever was in his way.

Jeff waited for Sergio to get to his dorm, glad to see that his roommates were also awake. A triple kill? Now that was going to be fun! He waited by the window and listened in to the conversation, their cheers causing him to grip his knife harder. They were celebrating Sergio's new catch and it bothered Jeff how easily they were complimenting (Y/n).

"It's about time you got a good-looking one!" Sergio's friend laughed. His dirty blond hair was tied up in a bun.

"Yeah. Are you getting laid?" His bearded friend was more explicit about his questions and clearly cared more about scoring than maintaining a long relationship.

Sergio simply laughed nervously and shook his head. "Not at all Erik. Screwing on the first few dates can lead to other problems early on." Sergio was as pure as they came and this angered Jeff either way. He could've been using (Y/n) just for sex and that would've bugged him. But working on something long-term? That was a threat.