You're so beautiful... {creepypasta}

Truth or Dare

"Truth or Dare?" Ben asks.

"Dare!!!" I say excitedly.

"I dare you to... go down to the kitchen and flirt to the Rake for at least 30 seconds." Ben says with humor in his voice.

"Is he still awake!?" I ask. That thing terrifies me. I can't even look at a picture of it without cringing. I scoot closer to Ben as I picture the Rakes face in my mind.

"He never sleeps." Ben says looking into my eyes and smiling creepily. I shiver. I never turn a dare down though. This is one of the reasons I never played truth or dare back home.

I nod slowly and grab Bens hand. I drag him down stairs. "You're coming with me." We get to the first floor and sure enough the rake is sitting on the table eating some kidneys or something. I twitch and sit next to him on the chair.

"So... C-come here o-often?" I say gagging. He looks at me with his creepy face.

"Yes. I'm here every night eating kidneys and other organs. From 10:00 to 8:00." He says with all seriousness. I look to Ben and he taps his wrist like a watch telling me that I still have time.

"Y-you have nice... Eyes?" I say and he just shakes head.

"Just go away." He says and continues to eat organs.

"Ok!" I say and run all the way back up stairs to bens room, leaving Ben alone down there. I get into his room and slam the door. I jump on the bed. And get under the blankets and hide.

"So you wanna be in my bed like that, huh?" He asks sitting on the bed. I remove the covers with a blush on my face. I curse at him under my breath.

"Truth or dare?" I ask.

"Dare! I like to live dangerously!" He says with a smirk.

"I dare you," I say. I say the next part quietly. "Let me in your game."

His eyes widen and get darker. He scowls. "No way!" He says angrily.

"So you chicken?" I ask raising an eyebrow. He mumbles something and nods his head with a pout. "So what does the chicken have to do for being chicken?" I ask him. I look away to think. I have an idea. I turn back around and he kisses me.

"That's what the chicken has to do!" He exclaims. I gasp.

"Stop stealing my kisses!!" I yell. "I'm saving them for- some... one."

"Oh really? Mm. Lets make it so you can't pick the same thing twice. Truth or truth!?" He says.

"You really think you're being funny don't you?" I ask. He's making me so irritated.

"No. I think in being smart!" He exclaimed loudly pointing at his head.

"Truth obviously..." I answer glaring at him.

"Who are you saving all your kisses for?" He asks. With a sigh I kiss him and look away. "I'm guessing it's not me, so you chicken?"

"Duh." I answer back shortly. He really thinks he's being funny.

This goes on for an agonizing amount of rounds and then its his turn again. "Truth or dare?"

"Dare" I answer. Every time I've had a dare I've done it and everyone I've had a truth so far I've had to kiss him so I'm pretty angry.

"I dare you to make out with me for 5 minutes. Then tell me I'm not the one who you want to spend all your kisses on!" He says quickly. I know he's tired and he's been acting more and more strangely. I've never turned downs dare and I'm not going to stop here.

I close my eyes and place my lips on his. In only a few seconds it becomes heated and I know that I can't stop it. I really do like him. I just like Jeff more. But that might be changing.

We make out for at least 3 of the 5 minutes when the door opens. "What the fuck is going on Ben!" Its Jeff. Oh no. Should I tell him it was all just a dare or would that make it worse. "What were the first words I said when I came back with her!?"

"Shut up Jeff!! You don't even know her like I know her!" Ben yells getting up from our tangled position in his bed.

"So what!" Jeff says pulling out his knife. "I'll get to know her!"

"You don't even know her fucking name Jeff!" Ben says pulling a sword off of his wall.

"OF COURSE I DO!!!!" Jeff yells. He seems to have a dangerous aura surrounding him. Ben, be careful.

"THEN SAY IT! SAY IT RIGHT NOW JEFF!" Ben yells. His eyes start to turn red and bleed. I caused this. This is all my fault.

Jeff doesn't answer. He doesn't know it. He's never asked. "HER NAME IS SOPHIA, JEFF! SHE'S BEAUTIFUL, KIND, FUNNY, SWEET, AND STUPID IN THE BEST WAY IMAGINABLE. THAT'S JUST THE HALF OF IT JEFF! YOU NEVER EVEN GOT A CHANCE TO SEE HER THE WAY I DID!" He yells and swings his sword at Jeff.

Oh no! The sword just barely touches Jeff's arm. But it makes him bleed. Jeff swings his knife at Ben and Ben blocks it. This can't be happening.

I look around the room for anything that can help. I grab the ocarina off the wall and play the Goron Lullaby from Zelda majora's mask. Nothing happens. No wonder. Were not in a video game. But Jeff looks from Ben to me and whispers to Ben something I wasn't suppose to hear. "She's perfect for you." Then he walks out of the room.

"Jeff." I whimper.

"That's your number one choice... isn't it. And who you were saving your kisses for?" Ben asks looking down.

I look away ashamed. I feel so bad, I feel like I lead Ben on. I was only playing the game. Even though I do feel something for Ben. Just, when I saw Jeff act like that I realized that I like him, so much. "You should leave..." Ben whispers.

"B-but Ben!" I say trying to look him in the eye. He looks away and points to the door.

"Please Sophia. Just go..." he says. Tears stream down my face as I run out the door. I run down all the stairs, not caring what creepypasta might be looking at me. Even if it's the Rake or Laughing Jack. I run out of the front mansion door and to my house.

We really should have went to sleep earlier in the night. Tired teenagers hanging out is just asking for something to go wrong. And with my luck of course it has to be something like that.

I run for 20 minutes straight. And finally make it home. The whole place is covered in police tape and blood. I to straight to the attic and fall asleep. I have to talk to her, tomorrow... this is too much to handle.