(Thank you to @i_spy_UwU for the ideas!)
Aries: Jeff the Killer
Taurus: Jane the Killer
Gemini: KageKao
Cancer: Sally Williams
Leo: Laughing Jack
Virgo: Lost Silver (Idk you make up the situation)
Libra: Ben Drowned
Scorpio: Eyeless Jack
Sagittarius: Candy Pop
Capricorn: Bloody Painter
Aquarius: Clocky
Pisces: Jason the Toy Maker
