The Girl Nextdoor

Convinced // 3

Nick woke up to see Noel was gone. He slowly got out of bed, remembering he was still wearing panties and a bra from last night.

He picked up his phone. 23 missed calls. Nick had forgotten to tell his Mom he was spending the night, he was dead. His Mom probably thought something bad had happened. The doorbell began to ring. Nick thought, who could it be? Could it be Noel's parents? No, she said they were away for a business trip and wouldn't be back for another 2 weeks.

Was it Noel? Maybe she went out to get some food or something. It couldn't be, she would have brought her keys. Then it hit him, it was his Mom. It made sense. Nick told his mom he would be at Noel's, so after not answering the 23 missed calls, she must have realised I was at her place.

The ringing stopped.

Nick heard footsteps slowly approach. First up the stairs and then to Noel's bedroom door. Nick quickly jumped into Noel's bed, afraid his Mom would see him in lingerie. The door slowly opened, his heart pounding against his chest.

It was Noel.

"Hey, sleepyhead! You finally decided to wake up." Noel joked. "Why do you look so nervous?"

"I uh-" Nick stumbled to form the right words.

"Aww, was someone embarrassed they were going to get caught?" Noel teased. "It was only your Mom asking if you were here. I told her you spent the night and she laughed then walked back home."

"You think she knows?" Nick asked.

"Knows what? That we had oral sex last night? Maybe. That you are wearing panties and a bra? No." Noel replied.

Nick blushed, "Okay, stop teasing me. I only wore this because of my boxers, remember?"

"You did? I assumed you wore it because you wanted to!" Noel said while laughing.

Nick ignored her walking to grab his clothes.

"What do you think you're doing, princess," Noel asked.

"Going to put my clothes on?" Nick responded.

"No, you are not. Wait here." Noel commanded, giving him a kiss on the lips and dragging him back onto the bed.

Noel turns around from her closet with a pile of clothes in her arms, again.

"Noel... I thought-" Nick said as he was cut off.

"Princess, please. For me?" Noel begged. She seemed pretty set on this idea of me being dressed up in dresses and skirts. "As I said, no one will even know. It will be fun, and I'll even give you a little reward if you do..."

Nick thought to himself, what was really the worst that could happen? He would put on a few outfits for Noel to see and then also have something waiting for him at the end.

"Alright, fine. But please, don't tell anyone. This is just between you and me." Nick pleaded with a nervous look on his face.

"Yes princess, thank you so much. You have no idea how much this means to me." Noel said with joy. She began to give him lots of kisses, reassuring him it would be all okay and that nothing bad would happen. If anything Nick could just turn around and tell Noel that he no longer wanted to continue, right?

Noel dropped the pile of clothes onto her bed and picks up a red floral dress that flowed just above his thighs and because of that, it showed the panties he wore underneath.

Noel ordered him to give her a twirl, doing so revealed his underwear and she blushed, enjoying the view. She never felt this way before, it was all so new, but she felt happy.

"I love you, Nicole," Noel said, pulling Nick in for a kiss.

"I love you too, but why did you just call me Nicole?" Asked Nick. There was no way he could ignore the fact she had just called him Nicole.

"Because that is your girl name, silly." She responded giving him another kiss.

"But I'm not a girl." He said.

"You are when you look like this, princess," Noel said with a smile. "It's okay, I like the way you look. You're cute."

Nick blushed not saying a word. He felt like his heart was melting. All the compliments on top of being with Noel made him feel special. Nick enjoyed everything that was happening but was afraid to admit it.

"Here, sit down, princess," Noel demanded gently pushing him towards her chair.

She spun him around so she could see his face and went to grab something. Noel emerged with a bag, inside was makeup. Foundation, highlighter, concealer, mascara, lipstick. You name it, she had it.

Nick went to stand up and protest when she nudged him back into the chair, "Come on, a girl can't be a girl without makeup!! You're already wearing panties, a bra and a dress. Might as well let me apply some makeup." Noel begged, her eyes looking into my eyes.

Nick just nods, knowing that he can't win this fight and lets her apply makeup.

Noel begins to instantly work on his makeup as if she was going to already, even if he had refused. After what felt like hours, she had finally finished. Nick was feeling tired but became wide awake to the sounds of Noel squealing at the sight of Nick.

She didn't allow him to see the finished product just yet, as she was eager to go get one final piece to finish the look. Noel returned with a brown wig that flowed just below his shoulders. She styled it to the best of her ability in order to make it look natural.

Noel spun him like a princess to see how he looked. Nick stared at the mirror and to his shock, he saw a 16-year-old girl staring right back at him. He was in shock. He couldn't even recognise himself.

"Oh my god-" Nick said, still trying to take everything in.

"You look amazing, princess!!" Noel said, with a genuine tone. She got behind Nick and gave him a hug before releasing him. "Time for pictures."

"Um, what did you say??" Asked Nick who looked like he had just seen a monster.

"I said it's time for pictures, princess. I wasn't asking." She replied with a big smile. Noel dragged Nick over in front of the full-sized mirror, and this time he got an even better look at himself. He was a girl from head to toe, even wearing a dress.

She nudged him towards the ground onto his knees, where Noel positioned him between her legs. Noel placed her chin on his left shoulder and wrapped her left arm around his waist. Nick felt loved.

"Princess?" Asked Noel.

"Yes?" Nick responded.

"Do you enjoy what we are doing?" Noel questioned. She wasn't too sure Nick actually enjoyed everything they've been doing but had a hunch that he wasn't bothered. Noel had been beginning to notice how compliant Nick was and even started to respond to his nickname of 'princess' without question.

Nick remained silent.

"Princess, I asked you a question," Noel asked with a slightly annoyed tone.

"I... I don't know..." He lied.

"I think that isn't true, baby girl," Noel said.

Nick blushed, feeling his face heat up. 'Babygirl'. Another girly nickname, but he enjoyed it. It made him feel happy, so he didn't mention it. 

"It is..." He lied again.

"No, it's not!" She yelled, lunging towards me and tickling every part of me. "Tell me the truth otherwise this will only get worse!"

Nick began to laugh hysterically, unable to form words. "S-s-top! P-l-e-ease." He continued laughing. Noel didn't stop.

"I-I'll s-s-say it j-j-just s-stop!!" Nick begged, taking deep breaths in between each word.

She continued for a few more seconds before finally coming to a halt. Noel waited eagerly, ready to continue if Nick wasn't going to tell her.