Little White Lies

Three

Caroline sighed as she walked to the Kissing Rock. Her mom thought it would have been a good idea for her and her friends to build a memorial for Alison just like Pam suggested. Wishing she could be at home with her daughter, but she was forced to do this. She hadn't said much as she was going to tell one of her friends about Kelsey being her's and not her mom's. "Caroline?"

"Hmm."

"You're quiet."

"I don't think this should be the spot. Think about how Alison would want it. She was the center of attention before she dies. Why not make it more public?"

Hearing something, all five looked, but there was no one in sight till a text came in saying they were being hunted.
~~~
The next day, Caroline had dropped Kelsey off at day care as she went to school. She figured out which friend she was going to tell. She saw Ben forcing a kiss on Emily. Caroline rolled her eyes. "You do know that she may not like the way you just kissed her."

"Caroline." Emily said. "Are you going to the party at Noel's cabin?'

"I don't know." She said. "I have to talk to mom to make sure she has no plans and two, I do need to talk to you about something."

"Okay."

Maya walked over to them as Caroline walked away. The blonde walked in smiling thinking about the party. The last time she went to a party, she ended up having a baby. When Caroline made it to her locker, she noticed everyone looking towards the entrance causing her to look. Her eyes widened as she saw Jenna and Toby. She had a flashback to the night that left Jenna blind. Toby took the blame, but that didn't solve any issues making her not trust him very much.

"Hey." Aria said as they saw Hanna go to the office.

"What's going on?"

"I don't know, but that's not good."

Caroline sighed as she walked away. Emily wondered what she had to say as they went to class.
~~~
Later that day, Emily went to Caroline's after the swim meet to tell her about Ben and Toby saving her. "Caroline, I'm gone to get dinner."

"Okay." She said as she looked at her daughter. "Mommy's little angel."

"Mommy?"

Caroline turned to see Emily. "Yeah. Remember that party we went to?" Emily nodded. "I got drunk and had a one night stand. The day Alison disappeared was the day I told him and we  were on our way back when we got in a bad wreck. I was the only one to survive."

"Why didn't you tell me you were pregnant? I would have helped you."

"I was scared." Caroline said with tears. "That's why."

Emily hugged her. "Never be scared to tell us. I knew Alison was hiding something."

"She was the first to know." Caroline said.

"Can I hold her?"

Caroline laughed and nodded as Emily held her. Kate walked in and stopped seeing Emily holding her grand baby. She was happy that Caroline told.
~~~
That night, the girls arrived at the party. Caroline walked to get a drink of water as she has spoken about not trusting Toby. Emily saw her friend sitting down making her think about talking about her attraction to Maya.
~~~
The next day, Caroline sighed. "We should think about this being in the public because our spot is not the same anymore and you all know that." She said. "I think Alison would like it if it was more public. The more people to look at her like the last time."

"I like that idea."

They heard a twig snap making Caroline and the girls run to see who was watching them. They kept running till the black figure disappeared. Caroline knew her idea was going to be put in action.