"WHY IS BEN BUILT LIKE AN 8 YR OLD" Creepypasta x Reader LONG fic

Tobussy 🥱 PT. 1

@JustASimp90 I'm stealing your comment

THIS CHAPTER IS VERY MUCH 18++ (here's ur fake ID u nasty ass sinner 🙄)

(I'M SORRY TO MY CIS MALE READERS AND MY MALE BODIED NON-BINARY READERS BUT Y/N WILL BE FEMALE BODIED HERE 😔)

(also I'm shy so I refuse to write the word pussy in any of my smut- I might say cunt though, If I'm feeling bold.) 

Narrator's POV:  

You sigh quietly as Toby runs his hands up and down your torso, your fingers find the zipper to his jeans and you pull it down, Toby shoves his pants down past his thighs and kicks them off entirely, rubbing his thigh between your legs, You gasp at the friction and tangle your hands in his hair.

Yours and Toby's lips part and you gasp for air, a string of saliva between you. "J-Jesus christ, Toby-" You say, as he quickly slips off your top and throws it at the wall. Toby lets his his eyes wander across your body before you clear your throat.

"Y-Yes?" He asks, Smiling. You roll your eyes playfully. "Quit staring." You chuckle, He nods.

He puts two of his fingers under the waistband of your underwear, looking up at you and quirking an eyebrow. "My safe word is Pineapple Juice."  You say, he smiles a crooked grin and pulls your underwear down to your ankles.

He leans down between your thighs, rubbing his cheek up against your inner thigh with a loving smile.

You can feel his hot, calm breathing leave tingles on your sensitive skin as he moves in closer. His head jolts to the side a few times and he looks irritated. To steady himself, e takes your thighs in his hands and presses them to each side of his face.

"Squeeze." He demands, his voice not faltering once as he stares up at you. the softness in his eyes seems so different from the power in his voice. 

You nod, squeezing your thighs against his head, not too hard, but not very gentle either.

You let your head fall backwards as Toby licks a stripe up between your delicate folds. you arch your hips into Toby's face slowly, but he places a scarred hand on your lower abdomen to keep you down.

"Toby.." you sigh, gripping the bedsheets in your fists as the brunette man gently slides his middle finger into your cunt, pumping slowly before adding another finger and pressing his tongue flat against your clit.

"J-Jesus, Toby- from the way y-you text, I thought- I thought you- were like- i-innocent, but.." You shake your head. Toby chuckles into your skin, sending the vibrations of his voice into your brain and diverting your thoughts into ones of Toby and Toby alone. No BEN. No insecurities. No self doubt. Just Toby.

A tight knot starts to build up in your stomach, you tangle your fingers into Toby's hair and tug him into your further, he leaves small nips and bites on your inner thighs as he picks up the pace with his fingers.

"T-Toby, I think I'm gonna-" "Whenever you're ready, Angel." You sigh and let your eyes flutter closed at the nickname. The knot in your stomach snaps and you let go completely, Yelling out Toby's name countless times as your vision blurs and your body tingles all over, you grip onto anything you can find for stability, Toby takes your hand in his own and slowly moves up your body with gentle kisses.

"Y-You okay?" He asks, resting his head on your chest for a moment, you nod, holding onto his hand tightly.

"AWWW DONE ALREADY?! IT WAS JUST GETTING GOOD!" Jeff yells from outside your door, Toby sits up and throws a pillow at the door. "OH S-SHUT IT YOU P-PERVERTED, FUCKING S-SCIENCE PROJECT!" He yells, You hear Jane laugh from down the hall.

You cover your face with your hands, embarrassed out of your mind, before Toby pulls your hands away and kisses your forehead. "I-I'm gonna go k-kill Jeff, I'll be back f-for round two in about twenty minutes, I love you." Before you can question the 'I love you' Toby is already out the door and chasing Jeff down the hall wearing only his jeans.

You rub your thighs together thinking about round two, but fear quickly floods into your expression when you realize BEN probably heard all of that. 

Oh well, early bird gets the worm.. wait- you'll be getting the worm. 😨😨