"WHY IS BEN BUILT LIKE AN 8 YR OLD" Creepypasta x Reader LONG fic

Doesn't that make you a whore 😐⁉️

Narrator's POV:

You're sitting in the basement with E.J. and Jeff, trying to get them to help you untangle your love triangle. "So you slept with both Ben and Toby?" E.J. asks, tilting his head, You nod, your cheeks red.

"Doesn't that make you a whore-" Jeff starts, E.J. throws a pillow at him.

"Jeff, don't be a dick. We're here to try and help Y/N." You smile. "Thanks E.J." He nods. "You gonna fuck him too- OW-" E.J. throws another pillow.

You sigh, standing up from your criss-cross-apple-sauce position on the floor and walking back up into the living room. Liu, Jane, Masky and Hoodie are sitting on the couch watching an old cooking show from 1993.

"What is she even making?" You ask, Liu shrugs. "Either meatloaf or spaghetti." you furrow your eyebrows at the TV but sit down between Masky and Liu anyways. "Hey, uh.. I heard about what happened with Ben and Toby, I know how you feel, relationships suck." Masky whispers, you bite the inside of your cheek. "Thanks, Tim." You say, he nods.

You all sit in peaceful silence until Toby, BEN and Jeff all come fucking tumbling into the room, yelling at eachother and even throwing a few fists, Toby and BEN end up infront of you, BEN looks angry and Toby looks hurt.

"uhm.. hi?" You question, getting slight goosebumps from the intensity in their eyes. "Y/N, do you lo-" Toby pauses. "You like me, right?" he continues, you appreciate the word choice. BEN elbows Toby in the side, Toby rolls his eyes, unable to feel any pain. "Y/N. C'mon." BEN says, gesturing to himself, You fumble over your words before Liu sticks his arm out infront of you.

"Are you guys fucking serious? Y/N obviously has feelings for both of you-" He makes a safety glance towards you, raising his eyebrows, you nod. "-So why the fuck would you make them choose? Do you even care about them at all?" Your heart softens at the protectiveness in his voice.

"of course we do!" Toby and BEN shout in unison, Liu rolls his eyes. "Then fuck off and let Y/N think things through." The boys both sigh and sulk out of the room, probably going out to kill more innocent people.

"Thank you, Liu. I appreciate it." You sigh, He smiles sympathetically, before his head twitches a few times, his eyes darkening, he smirks at you. "Anytime those guys bother you, you come straight to us, I'll kick their asses for you and Liu will hug you afterwards." You quirk an eyebrow at the change of character before the memories of simping for Liu Woods in your Creepypasta phase when you were fourteen flood back.

"Sully?" You ask, tilting your head to the side, he grins. "You know who I am, huh?" You nod. "Cool. mind if I expose everyone in this room real quick, doll?" You scoff at the nickname but nod your head eagerly nonetheless. "Alright, so, Liu has a fat crush on you, Jane has you as her phones lock screen, Masky has you saved as 'cutie' in his contacts, Hoodie recently shot your ex-boyfriend dead-He claims its a coincidence, but it's not-Jeff jerks off to you, and I think your a sexy son-of-a -bitch." 

Your jaw drops and everyone in the room glares at Sully. Holy fucking shit.. HOLY FUCKING SHIT-

Yeah <3

       - regina george