sub!Nightmare sans one-shots {Requests Open!}

An Odd Encounter... 🚫💦

Ship: ---mare

Top: Noah/Villager Bottom: Nightmare

( Remember my own hc is Corrupted & Passive ARE the same unless you suggest it in the next one :) If you don't like or are uncomfy you can leave or read one of my different stories!)

Type: Forced 🚫💦

TW: Cursing, P3dophila, Manipulation, and SA (sexual assault)

this is for story purposes ONLY 

( past NM)

Narrator pov

Nightmare was going for a midnight walk in Dreamtale, he loved it. It was peaceful and he didn't have to worry about any type of abuse. As Nightmare came to an Alleyway he decided to head back, but he began writing in his book and got carried away. He started walking further down the Alleyway to shady parts, he was lucky not to get kidnapped, " Oof!" Nightmare accidentally bumped into an older man, he was in his 34s and wasn't bad looking, Nightmare had just celebrated his 17th birthday with his brother, since they were twins," Ah Shit!" The man said as he had dropped his phone into a puddle of water. Nightmare quietly gasped and began immediately apologizing, the man looked at Nightmare, he seemed to be deciding what to do with him. The man sighed and said it was okay, his eyes saying otherwise, Nightmare felt so bad he asked if the man needed anything or if the man wanted any help from Nightmare, and also," Please I feel awful I'll do anything to make it up to you mister! But please don't hurt me!" The man chuckled and simply said, "there is one thing, but I don't think you can do it..." Nightmare shook his head and insisted he would help, the man asked how old he was, and Nightmare answered the question truthfully.

The man smiled and asked if he was okay following him, Nightmare was not aware of "stranger danger" since his school didn't care much for it. Nightmare nodded and soon found himself in the man's living room," So uh... What's your name cutie?" the man said, winking at Nightmare. Nightmare blushed, as he had never been complimented before," Oh, it's Nightmare..." He said as he looked away, clearly embarrassed. " That's quite pretty actually, how about Moonshine as a nickname?" The man stated obviously sensing Nighmare's embarrassment. Nightmare looked at the man and smiled, "yes please!" The man seemed curious about something, Nightmare asked what he was thinking. The man hesitated, but decided to ask," Uh this is probably odd to ask, but are you able to be any gender? I researched about it and it said your kind were able to?" Nightmare was getting quite comfortable with this man and decided to answer," Actually yes! Not all kinds can but I know I can" Nightmare giggled a little at the end. " Uh, real quick what's your name?" " Oh, it's Noah. Here follow me we'll go to my bedroom."

NSFW STARTS HERE ONLY WARNING

It had been a few hours later and Noah asked Nightmare to help him with something," Just relax." Noah said as he let Nightmare form a female body," Woah" Noah said as he looked at Nightmare, as he walked out of the bathroom. Nightmare wasn't flat that's for sure, actually quite the opposite. Nightmare covered his face with his hands and whined quietly, Noah hugged him and gave him more compliments, Nightmare inhaled softly and lowered his hands. Noah had wanted to play a game, so they played truth or dare, and Nightmare chose dare. Now he was in a fluffy, cute, little cow outfit with the horns, and bell around his neck too, it covered his tits and genitals a little, but still left a lot of exposure everywhere. Noah chuckled at his little Moonshines actions," How about we play a different game~?" Nightmare blushed and nodded, not aware at all. " Okay how about a mystery game?" Nightmare smiled," I love mysteries! What's the game?" Noah smirked," That's the thing you don't know!" Nightmare happily gasped and nodded," Let's do it!"

Noah smiled and got up, he returned with a blindfold and an odd-looking mouth wrap," You ready Moonshine?" Nightmare once again nodded. 

Once the "game" was ready

Nightmare was seated on Noah's lap in his bedroom and was excited. Noah started by rubbing Nightmare's hips, up and down, Nightmare shivered with anticipation. Noah's hands made their way up to Nightmare's tits, Nightmare leaned back and tensed," Relax Moonshine, I won't hurt you" Nightmare did calm down as his shoulders relaxed a little more than before. Noah's hands slipped beneath the fabric and began groping Nightmare's tits, Nightmare had never felt this before, he loved it, Nightmare mewled only for it to be almost silent," My, my, my! You are very sensitive!" Noah exclaimed as he flipped Nightmare around, and began licking his way down to Nightmare's nipple, licking around the sensitive bud before lightly sucking on it. Nightmare's head was tilted back slightly, as drool began to pool around the odd rubber that was in his mouth, blocking any drool to come out. Nightmare was moving only a little though, Noah didn't mind though, continuing to lick the now a darker shade of lavender, a bruise was forming. Nightmare closed his eyes as he felt Noah begin to pull and push on his tits, Noah began getting a little eager to touch this little Moonshine he had persuaded. Noah gently laid Nightmare down on his mattress. Nightmare felt a leash connect to the ring on the top of the bell, Nightmare quivered as he felt the fabric covering his genitals be stripped off, Noah licked his teeth and leaned down to Nightmare's clit. Nightmare jerked and muffled a moaned as he felt Noah begin to lick his clit," MmM~Mnnh! MHhnm~" Nightmare moaned out trying to get the rubber off him, Noah smiled and took it off," Go on my Moonshine~ Don't be afraid to moan.~"

Noah looked at Nightmare and smirked," Hey Moonshine~?" he said sitting up," Do you wanna take it a step further, it'll be fun~" Nightmare turned his head," I mean I guess?" Noah smiled and walked to his closet. He came back with handcuffs and locked Nightmare's hands back on the headboard, Nightmare jumped a little but trusted him. "Open." Noah ordered Nightmare, "Okay?" Nightmare opened his mouth and realized Noah had shoved his fingers in his mouth, Nightmare tried to speak, but Noah growled and said, "Suck." Nightmare hesitated but did so. Noah smiled and took his two fingers out and stuck them in Nightmare's pussy, Nightmare moaned and looked at Noah, he loved the feeling and yet he felt so wrong doing it. Nightmare struggled as he felt Noah begin to fasten his actions, Nightmare moaned out his name and pleaded for him to slow down just a little, Noah just smirked and went even faster. "No-OaH-h Ple-AaA-" Noah grabbed his chin and paused his actions " No, Call me Master~" Nightmare nodded and begged his "Master" to keep going. When Noah began slowly he kept that pace, Nightmare pleaded and begged, but Noah laughed and shook his head. Nightmare ccouldn'thandle the overstimulation and began to pass out. When Noah noticed this he paused and went up to Nightmare's neck and began biting and sucking on it, Nightmare gasped and bit his lip. Noah felt dissatisfied and got out a dildo, but Nightmare was still fighting to stay awake. Noah growled and shoved it up Nightmare's pussy, Nightmare screamed in pain, he wasn't ready at all. Noah smirked and stroked Nightmare'a tears away, Nightmare was still crying but Noah didn't care. He began thrusting the silicone piece in and out. Nightmare began thrashing around pleading and screaming for him to stop.

Hours later

Nightmare had a gag over his mouth as he yanked on the cuffs on his arms, Noah smirked and kept thrusting in and out with his dick, he was getting closer, his thrusts getting sloppier as he tightened his grip on Nightmare's waist. Hours had gone by and Nightmare was so close, but every time Noah would stop and wait then handjob himself to finish, covering Nightmare in cum. Noah decided to finally let Nightmare finish, he loved how Nightmare felt and sounded. Nightmare finally orgasmed and almost broke the chains on his wrists, Noah was super close and Nightmare began to realize, that if he came inside of his he would get pregnant for sure, he began thrashing around and muffling pleas for him to pull out. Noah wanted to hear his pleas and screams so he tore off the mouthpiece, Nightmare began begging him to stop and moving his body, Noah smirked this would be even better for him," Fine, but you have to come here every day. Only then I will pull out and I'll use your mouth instead." Nightmare nodded as Noah crawled up to his face," Better start sucking Princess, or I may go back to fucking that pussy." Nightmare opened his mouth as Noah immediately forced Nightmare to begin deepthroating him, Nightmare didn't have a gag reflex, but as Noah came into Nightmare's throat Nightmare choked on the semen going down his throat. Noah smirked as Nightmare passed out from the overstimulation, pain, and pleasure still flowing through him.

1532 words