Creepypasta x Reader

Ticci Toby x Reader

You go for a walk around your neighborhood late at night. The sidewalk was illuminated sparsely by random street lights. You were in your own little world not noticing that you were being followed.

"B-boo," a voice yelled in your ear causing you to scream and jump. Causing a fit of laughter to erupt from behind you.

"TOBY DON'T SCARE ME LIKE THAT!" you screamed as you hit him playfully on the arm.

"Why are you out here so late?" he asked.

"I like the night," you answered. That was a lie. You secretly wanted to see the boy who was slightly taller than you, had short brown hair and very kind eyes. You had had a crush on him since you met him.

You two walked together talking about your days. Every time Toby spoke he always had a slight stutter that he hated, but you loved.

Sadly though you two had made the whole way around your neighborhood and returned to your empty house. As you said goodbye to each other you got the boldest--well at least you thought it was--idea.

"Wait Toby..." you called back to him. As he turned around to see what you needed you pulled him into a kiss. Your bodies melded together deepening the kiss. Toby's tongue brushed against your bottom lip asking for entrance which you gladly did. Your tongues collided with each other, making you moan and weak in the knees.

"I've always liked you," you said breathless.

"I've always liked you too (y/n)," Toby said with a small amount of blush on his face, making you smile. He pulled you even closer to him, that's when you felt a bulge in his pants making you blush even more.

"Come with me," you said as you grabbed Toby's arm and took him into your house and to your room. You two fall on top of your bed not separating from your kiss. You then started peeling eachothers clothes off. You then laid on top of Toby's chest stroking his full length.

"Ah~" you heard a moan escape his mouth. A smirk stretched across your face before you put his hard member deep into your mouth. You began to move your head up and down having the delicious taste cover every inch of your mouth. That's when Toby glided his fingers against your wet core making you moan loudly.

Suddenly without warning he entered a finger inside you, and began moving it in and out. He then added two more. You couldn't take it any longer.

"TOBY... ~" you screamed as you came. This got a laugh from the boy.

"Y-you li-liked that (y/n)?" he said sarcastically. You then wrapped you hands around his big hard member and began stroking it.

"Yes," you said happily." Now it's your turn." Then you put his member all the way in your mouth and began moving you hard back and forth, fast. You could hear Toby moan more and without any warning he came filling your mouth until it began trickling out the sides. You swallowed all of it.

Toby then flipped you over so he was now on top. "N-now it's time for b-both of us to have fun together," he said as he positioned himself at your opening.

"Yes please," you said before he entered deep inside you. He waited until you gave him the OK to move. He started moving slowly and gradually picked up speed. You moaned louder the more he moved.

"Toby... yes... ah ~...I'm going to...," you panted between moans.

"M-me to... (y/n)," Toby said as he moved even faster until he released himself inside you making you scream his name.

He laid beside you and you snuggled into him. Then you fell asleep in each others arms.