request: 🥃+ "Did you just tell the person I was gonna go out with that we're dating?" +pre-serum Steve roger,Steve Grant, Peter parker - nana1000night
pairing: college!skinny!steve rogers x fem!reader x college!steven grant; college!peter parker x fem!reader
word count: 526
warnings?: college au, not proofread
note: changed the prompt slightly bc this sparked an idea and it didn't perfectly fit the prompt. instead, i used "Did you tell my boyfriends that you have a crush on me?"
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
You had always been oblivious of people's interest in you. Ever since you were at an age where kids started being interested in dating, it completely flew over your head when awkward pre-teens would try to ask you out to the movies or a dance or whatever else it was that was deemed an acceptable date-spot at that age. Which, in some ways, was why it was surprising when you got to college and found yourself with not just one but two boyfriends.
Steve and Steven—it almost sounded like something that could be in a cute polyamorous romance novel. They were the sweetest guys you'd ever met. A little confused about relationships, like you, but always eager to make sure everyone in the relationship was happy and satisfied with the relationship. It was a breath of fresh air in comparison the arguments you'd overhear between the sweet cheerleader and her frat bro/business major boyfriend.
You loved your boys so much. Loved holding Steve in your arms when you cuddled in bed, the poor guy perpetually freezing. Loved watching documentaries with Steven. Loved going to bingo nights that Student Life would put on—loved even more that one time that Steven won a big basket of movies and popcorn and snacks, because that meant your weekend would be full of snuggles as you watched the movies.
But, still, even with such a loving relationship, you were still completely and utterly oblivious to other people's interest in you. Which was why when you stood with Peter Parker in the cafe in the library, having met there to work on a project for your Latin class, staring at Steve and Steven, who had come to get some coffee before their evening classes, you were shocked to find that Peter had a humongous crush on you.
"Hey, Steve! Steven!" Peter said when he saw them, waving them over. "This is Y/N, the girl I was telling you about?"
"Huh? You talk about me?" you said.
Peter's cheeks tinted pink. "Uh, well, yeah. Just a little bit. I, uh, have a crush on you, and I've been working up the nerve to ask you out and uhhh—"
You glanced back at Steve and Steven, the former holding back a laugh while the latter looked confused. "Pete...Did you tell my boyfriends that you have a crush on me?"
Peter's eyes widened, eyes flitting between you and the boys. "Boy...boyfriends?"
"We've been dating for three years, Pete. Did they not tell you?"
"Hey, hey now!" Steven interrupted. "We didn't know he was talking about you, love!"
"Though, we should have suspected based on how highly he spoke of you," Steve said. "There's only one woman as brilliant at you."
"I-I'm sorry," Peter squeaked.
"Hey, it's no big deal, Pete," you said. "We can just put this behind us! No need to make a big deal of it all."
"Well..." Steve said. "Perhaps, there can be some teasing."
"Just a smidge," Steven agreed. "It only makes sense, doesn't it?"
You groaned. "Better get used to this, Pete. When those two team up on something, they're relentless."
