A few days had passed and everything seemed to be bumbling along as normal. No more surprise visits from mobsters, no more outlandish tips. The bakery had its steady buzz of happy customers and business was good.
You'd been trying out a new carrot cake recipe during a late afternoon lull the following Monday. Wanda was out sick so it was just you, but that was okay because Mondays were always quiet and you could handle things alone. You hadn't had a customer in over an hour so were in the back mixing when you heard the bell going.
"Be right there!" You called to the front of the shop.
You wiped your hands on your apron, cursing at what a mess you'd made. Your forehead was sweaty and you had butter and flour over your clothes in spite of the apron. Oh well. Hopefully you wouldn't scare the customer off...
You wandered back to the front of the store to find a tall gentleman in a fancy suit with his back to you, engrossed in his phone. Probably a business type popping in for a late afternoon sugar hit. You got a lot of those.
"Hi sir, how can I help today?" You ask as you take your place at the counter.
The man spins to face you and you can't help but gasp in surprise when you see who it is. James Barnes. He's back. He looks as slick as he did last time, immaculate in his tailored suit. His hair is carefully coiffed with a hint of gel, not a single strand out of place. Still gorgeous, too.
He smirks at your reaction.
"Surprised to see me, Doll?" He asks playfully.
"Sorry Mr Barnes, I didn't realise it was you" you explain. You try to ignore how his nickname for you sends shivers down your back.
"Well, I just enjoyed your merchandise so much last week I had to drop by again".
You smile at him warmly, dropping his gaze because it's so intense that it almost feels wrong to look at him directly.
"Great to hear that. So what would you like today?" Your professional veneer is hanging on by a thread.
He ignores your question and his eyes drop to your messy apron.
"What are you making?" He asks.
You fumble with the apron, embarrassed by your dishevelled appearance in contrast to his well-groomed figure. You must look like such a messy slob to him.
"Oh...just some carrot cake. I'm tweaking the recipe. Had a bit of a quiet period so thought I'd get a jump start" you chuckle nervously.
Why are you nervous?
You know why you're nervous.
He nods and smiles, scrutinising your appearance briefly before he looks back to the counter.
He begins to pick out cakes and pastries again, meticulously studying each section of the display case as he points out what he wants with a gloved finger. He asks for specific choices too. 'That doughnut third from the back' or 'that cookie second from the front'. You begin to understand that James Barnes is a man who likes things just so. And you would bet good money that he's like that in his day job, too.
You pack up selections and ring him up, it's harder to keep up this time without Wanda. You take his credit card once again and he tries to pass you another obscenely high bill from his wallet.
"Oh I can't accept that" you explain, waving your hand at it.
He laughs. "Why not?"
"You already over tipped me last week. Honestly, Mr Barnes, you don't need to do that. Thank you, but really. You already spend so much here". You smile awkwardly at him, knowing full well he's going to fight you on this.
James chuckles. "I hope you're not telling me what I can or can't do with my own money, Doll..."
"Oh, no, of course not. It's just..." but you have no words for him. No excuses. Not without telling him that you feel uncomfortable taking cash from a mob boss, anyway.
He nods. "That's what I thought" he tells your firmly. In a single fluid motion he rolls the note up and leans over the counter, placing it inside your apron pocket.
You laugh. "Ass" you mutter quietly as you smile to yourself.
The word slips out before you can stop it. You clasp your hand over your mouth in surprise as if you can put it back in, but that horse has already bolted.
James' brows furrow. "What did you say?" He asks you accusingly. His eyes narrow and you see a brief glimpse of the scary man you'd seen on the news.
"Nothing. Nothing. I'm sorry...nothing" you reply casually, busying yourself with stacking up his boxes. You feel sick suddenly.
How could you forget yourself so carelessly?
He leans forward, the beginnings of a smirk on his lips. "Did you just call me an ass?" he asks as his eyes burn into you.
You try to think of a lie but his smirk is contagious and suddenly you're giggling.
"Oh, this is funny is it?" He asks. But his voice is soft, his face amused. It's clear this has tickled him.
"God, I genuinely am sorry" you tell him as you compose yourself. "That was so unprofessional. Really - I'm sorry".
"Why did you call me that?" He asks, watching you.
"Just...." You motion with your hand and copy the gesture he did of putting the money in your pocket. "I don't know. It just came out. The money thing was so smooth" you try to explain.
James stares at you like you're insane for a moment before chuckling earnestly. It stops you in your tracks briefly because it sounds like an authentic laugh, not the hollow snigger he seems to try to and undermine you with.
"Okay. You get that one for free, but only because nobody else is here" he advises as he shoots you a wink.
You laugh but part of you is shaken by his warning. You know full well it might have been a different story if you'd done that in front of his men.
As he begins to pick up the boxes you realise he's outnumbered - metal arm or not.
"Do you want help carrying those?" You ask.
James shakes his head and curls his lip like you've offended him. But then he tries to balance them all in his arms with one under his chin and it's clear it's not a one man job. Even a notorious man.
"Let me just take some. Are you parked up out front? C'mon, let me earn my tip. It'll make me feel better about taking all your money" you smile at him.
James smirks back at you. "Fine. But only for your sake, not mine".
You nod, grabbing a few boxes and opening the door. You follow him to his car parked on the street, a slick black SUV with windows so heavily tinted you don't think they can be legal. The trunk flies open despite James' full hands and for a second you think it's got motion detectors or something equally clever before you notice the man in the front seat.
"Hi again" the bearded blond turns and waves to you.
You smile back at him. Thor? No. Steve. Steve was his name.
"Hi" you reply shyly.
James begins packing the boxes up in the trunk and you follow with yours, ensuring they're secure and that the contents aren't likely to fly out if Steve makes a particularly sharp turn.
"There you go" you tell James sweetly as he slams the trunk down.
"Five star service" James says with a wink. "Thank-you, Doll".
"You're welcome Mr. Barnes" you nod as you wave and walk back to the bakery.
"Doll..." he calls to you.
You turn to face him once more.
"Call me Bucky" he grins.
"Bucky" you repeat back to him, feeling the name on your tongue, rolling it around in your mouth, trying it on for size.
YOU ARE READING
Sweet and Sour
FanfictionBucky Barnes Mob AU x Female Reader * You're hard at work in Pepper's Bakery when notorious mob boss James 'Bucky' Barnes darkens your doorway one normal afternoon and life is never the same again.