It was never part of the plan (Usui Takumi x OC)

Torn between two Usui's

 One might think that when dating Usui, there's no such thing as Valentine's Day because everyday is celebration of love but of course, that's just him. Being Mia, she always stress out in these holidays, she wants something special, possibly because her parents used to send her and Annie away on February 14th so that they can have their own spaces from screaming children. So since birth, Mia was taught that this day was special.

 What is even more special this year is that she actually has a boyfriend that she was madly in love with but he still has that to find out. The girl was planning to tell him her actual feelings on this day. She was nervous, excited, scared, delighted, Mia's heart was soaring with love.

 Putting the chocolate bar carefully in her bag, the girl sprinted to school, in hoping to see the blond. Running through the gate, she saw Misaki waved her 'Good luck!', she waved back, continuing her journey to class. Opening the door, the brunette looked inside, searching for the certain figure ... But he wasn't there.

 The next few periods, they don't share the same class so Mia didn't put her hopes up. But even at lunch time, he was nowhere to be found. 'That's weird.' she thought. After school, the girl was walking home, she almost forgot about the rectangular present lying underneath the bag. Reaching for a scarf to wear, her hand found the chocolate bar that she spent all evening making, her heart welded with disappointment. She smiled sadly to herself, looked up and saw a familiar apartment building. His condo was lit.

 Mia hesitantly rang the door bell while her mind filled with thoughts of why she didn't see him or what should she say. Suddenly, the door opened, revealing a blond.

 "Welcome!" he said, signifying her to come in and she did.

 "So, Happy Valentine's Day!" she wished in a jolly mood.

 "Yeah, do you want something to eat?"

 "Sure, I'm starving."

 The 2 went into the kitchen and the boy tried to cut up some apple for both of them but failed miserably. At least they had a good laugh about it.

 "I think Usui mentioned you before." Mia said suddenly "You're Usui's brother from England, right?" she turned to the man and he was stunned as ever.

 "Very keen eyes." he praised, removing his wig and contact lens, revealing dark navy hair and dark blue eyes "I applaud you. How did you know?" he asked in curiosity.

 "First, Usui's hair is much more disheveled, his eyes are of darker green than the contact, he never greets me like that and most importantly he's a skilled cook." she explained.

 "Impressive!" he said, turning back to the apple.

 "Thank you!" she thanked with a triumph smirk on her face. Right when she said that, a scream emerged from the man, turns out, he has cut his finger. Suddenly, about 10 other men rushed into the room from unknown direction, all raced toward the man, shouting:

 "Are you okay, Gerald-sama?" and they wrapped his finger in a huge cast. All the time, Mia was standing there, thinking 'Is this really necessarily? It's just a cut.'

 Then at that right movement, in walk the person all have been waiting for: Usui Takumi with a confused look on his face as he observed the situation.

 "Welcome home, Takumi!" Gerald said, glaring a bit at the boy "I thought it was rude to leave a lady waiting outside in the cold so I let her in. Is that alright?"

 "Yes, thank you!" he replied coldly.

 "I also caused a bit of a mess in the kitchen."

 "I don't care, but ... What did you come all the way here for?" Usui spoke in English.