Jealousy || Jenna Ortega x Reader [GP]

Part 5

During their drive to Y/N's house from school, she kept blabbering on about Natalie and how much the plan was working. But once she regained her senses and noticed that Jenna was in a mood she stopped quickly.

"Can you drive any slower? We have a project to do," Jenna was annoyed but Y/N couldn't understand why.

"I'm sorry if I made you upset," Y/N apologized.

"Stop apologizing to me. You didn't do anything wrong. If anyone's sorry it should be me. I don't know why I snapped like that," Jenna expressed.

There was a silence.

"Hey, if this plan isn't working for you. We can always just stop. Logan doesn't seem to be reacting to us and I know Natalie and you have a past so if things get too uncomfortable please let me know," Y/N reassured the other girl.

"What past? What are you talking about?" Jenna was confused.

"Well, I was told something happened back when we were kids. I'm not too sure," Y/N fibbed not wanting to snitch on her best friend.

   "Y/N," Jenna sat up in her seat and turned so she was fully facing Y/N, "Tell me."

   "I- Uh. I don't know, Jenna," Y/N said while pulling into her driveway. "Hey looks like my family's home. You can meet them," she said changing the subject. Jenna was annoyed but let it slide and stepped out of the car.

Once they entered the house they walked toward the living room and was greeted by Y/N's two siblings. "Zach! Get off of me you rat," Y/N playfully exclaimed trying to get her 6 year-old brother off her back. Next joined Zach's twin sister, Zoe, attacking Y/N by grabbing her leg and clinging on for dear life. The two children screamed as Y/N was flinging and spinning them around with her.

Jenna stood back and watched laughing along with them when all of a sudden she feels someone staring at her. She looks to her right and notices a women in her late 30s waving for her to enter the kitchen. The smaller girl complied, "Hi! You must be Y/N's mom it's so nice to meet you," she greeted with her hand out.

"Oh my gosh please come here," her mom pulled Jenna into a hug which the latter gladly accepted.

"If Y/N brought you home you must be something special," she complimented, "only friend she's ever brought home is that girl Natalie."

Jenna grinned, "Thank you Mrs, Y/L. You're home very is beautiful."

"Oh stop it!" the older woman gushed.

"Hey, Ma looks like you've met Jenna. Jenna this is Ma," Y/N smiled. "And this is Butt-Muncher and Booty-Sniffer," she introduced as Zach and Zoe respectively.

"Hey!" the twins exclaimed. Jenna and Ma chuckled at the teasing.

Zach and Zoe both grabbed each of Jenna's hands and walked her toward their playroom asking her random questions about herself.

"Alright guys. I need Jenna right now. You guys can have her later," Y/N interrupts.

"Oh man," they sighed.

"It's okay guys. I'll try to sneak away early so we can hang out," Jenna winked at them. The twins faces lit up and they went back to playing their toys.

"Let's get this project started," the smaller girl turned to Y/N and they started their way up the stairs and into Y/N's room.

They sprawled they're notes and books on to Y/N's bed and began their work. It took them about 3 hours for them to complete the amount they had planned to do for the day.

"Okay so now that we're done. I need answers," Jenna said seriously.

"Look Jenna. I don't really know much. I just heard some things so I'm sorry for bringing it up," Y/N stated still not wanting to snitch on Natalie. Jenna hated being lied to.

The petite girl sat up from her end of the bed and crawled towards Y/N. "I thought I told you to stop apologizing ," she stated now inches away from Y/N's face.

Jenna straddled Y/N's lap and put her hands behind the girl on the head board. "I don't like being lied to."

"I'm not lying," Y/N gulped.

Jenna now has her full weight on Y/N. Only thing between them were their clothes. The taller girl's thoughts were running wild and she was certain Jenna felt something because she started to shift a bit in her lap.

"Jenna," Y/N grabbed her hips, "Fine I'll tell you."

"Good," Jenna smiled still straddling the other girl's lap.

"Can you get off now?" Y/N shyly asked.

"No, this is for insurance."

Y/N sighed, "Okay so Natalie just told me that when we were younger you had apparently tried to take me from her and she's pretty pissed off about it."

Jenna not believing that that was all, she pushed her hips into the other girls. Y/N's member rubbed against Jenna's hot area. They both suppressed a moan.

"Okay okay! She also said that she wouldn't be surprised if that girl at the cafe was Logan's real girlfriend and that you were just trying to steal him from her!" Y/N spewed quickly. But Jenna kept going. "That's all I know I swear!"

At this point Jenna wasn't even focused, she kept grinding on Y/N and the latter wasn't fighting it anymore.

Y/N gripped onto her hips and started moving the smaller girl with her. Both girls were breathing heavily, too shy to look into each others eyes so they just stared down towards there hips. Watching each time their areas bumped and touched through their clothes.

Y/N flipped Jenna over. She was about to lean in for a kiss, but then she heard familiar ringtone.

Natalie! She thought.

Y/N jumped off the bed and towards her phone that sat on her desk. Leaving a very frustrated Jenna still lying on the bed.

"Hey Nat... yeah of course... it's okay... I'll be there in a few... alright bye," with that Y/N hung up.

"Natalie wants to meet up and talk! She said she didn't like how our last conversation went and that she was super sorry and oh my gosh she's so jealous Jenna!" Y/N paused.

Her eyes scanned the room for the girl, "Jenna?"

She checked her bathroom, Jenna wasn't there. She ran down the stairs and there Jenna was playing with Zach and Zoe.

"Hey why'd you leave?" Y/N asked coming up behind the 3 playing.

"Seems like our time was cut short today. You go ahead with Natalie. I'll leave after I play with the kids," Jenna said.

Y/N noticed her face was cold. God dammit Y/N what did you do now?

"Uh, alright. Thanks. Wouldn't be able to do this without you!" Y/N exclaimed while walking towards her front door.

Jenna watched as Y/N left. She felt a something but she wasn't sure what it was though.

Sadness? Loneliness? Jealousy? No way that's stupid. I just miss my friend. Is she my friend?

No, it's all fake.