𝐒𝐂𝐑𝐄𝐀𝐌

Caught

Tw: gore, murder

"I'm going to lose my mind."

"Chris stop being a little bitch."

"We're caught! We're done for! Did you see the look they gave us?! They know!"

My two brothers screamed at each other as we brainstormed in Nick's room. They think, well, I do a little too, but they think the three others are onto us.

"UGH, NICK! WHAT ARE WE GONNA DO?!"

"I DONT FUCKING KNOW! IT WOULD HELP IF YOU SHUT THE FUCK UP FOR A SECOND AND NOT BE STUPID AND GET US CAUGHT!"

I raised my eyebrows in shock. This happens all the time but it's still so funny to see.

"ME?! YOU SAID OKAY! YOU ARE THE ONE IN CHARGE SO YOU SHOULD'VE DONE SOMETHING IF YOU WEREN'T OKAY WITH IT!"

"UHM HELLO? I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW YOU WERE DOING IT IN THE FIRST PLACE!"

"KID WE ARE LITERALLY REAL LIFE SCREAM CHARACTERS! WE MURDER PEOPLE ON A DAILY BASIS-"

A loud thump interrupted the two. We all turned our heads to see our best friend with her hand left open and her phone on the ground.

"Just as I fucking said."

She backed away slowly, all of us sharing a look.

"Madi,"

"Nicolas Sturniolo... Please tell me you are not who I think you are."

"Madi, just listen to me-"

"Nicolas Antonio Sturniolo. What have you done."

Nick held his head down in shame. We all shared the same face, knowing we're screwed.

"Madi, I'm sorry."

Chris and I looked at each other. Nick gave us a nod and we immediately sped walked over to Madi.

"Nick!"

She shouted. A part of me felt horrible, and the other part was telling me to cut her up until she was unrecognizable.

"Guys- Please!"

We kept walking towards her, she took a glance towards the stairs. It would be impossible for her to escape. We cornered her, not knowing what much else to do. We could hear Alahna showering in her room, she wouldn't hear us.

"It shouldn't have been this way Mads."

Chris sighed, signaling me to walk up to her. I hesitantly stepped towards her, taking a grip on her neck.

"I'm sorry."

I whispered. She grabbed onto my arms, trying to pry me off. I gave her one last sympathetic smile then shoved the knife sideways through her face. She gasped when I let go and loosened my grip. She fell to the floor, grabbing onto her cheeks as she bled. I crouched down and stabbed her one last time in the throat. She eventually choked on her blood and stopped breathing.

"Jesus. Dramatic much?"

Chris joked. I rolled my eyes, carrying her into Nick's room. He sighed, taking a look at her.

"Throw her out."

"Just like that? No proper funeral or burial?"

"No. People will find out."

He kept himself turned away. I knew he wasn't trying to be a dick, he just didn't want to see his best friend in such a state. I sighed, looking outside the window. Right under us was a dumpster. Chris and I could just drop her there and clean up.

"Nick, are you sure?"

"Yes Chris! Just hurry up and clean before Alahna sees."

His voice wavered at the end of his sentence. He really didn't want this to happen. Chris opened the window and I dropped the girl directly into the large dumpster. She'd get picked up in around 10 hours by the garbage men.

"Let's clean up."

Chris whispered to me as Nick walked to his restroom. I nodded, running to my room to grab the supplies. While I was on my way, I noticed three bags in our living room.

Oh c'mon!

It was Willow, Bailey, and Noah's bags. They didn't pick them up after school so they were left here.

"Houston we have a problem!"

I yelled to Chris. He peeked his head from above.

"What?"

I pointed to the three bags and he groaned loudly.

"Can't we just leave it here?"

"Depends on what Nick says."

He sighed as I ran back up with the supplies. We cleaned up the mess, it wasn't too hard since it was fresh. Either way, it sucked.

"How do you think Nick's doing?"

"I don't know. He really liked Madi. They were like platonic soulmates."

He nodded, chucking the bloody towels into Nick's trash bin. He was on his bed now, simply scrolling through his phone.

"Hey Nick?"

"What?"

He spoke blandly. Both Chris and I were nervous.

"Willow, Bailey, and Noah left their bags here..."

Nick lifted his head, looking at us to see if we were serious. He then sighed and stood up.

"I guess we're going to a party then."

A/n: shorter chap but that's because I made this in like 30-45 minutes cuz I have zero motivation to keep up with this. Oh yeah, my one year of watching the triplets is coming up. Crazy how time flies.