the two boys i fell in love with // m.s (2023)

Arguement

Olivia's POV:
"Matt!" I said nothing else. I hugged him tightly not letting go. Rain started pouring down but neither one of us cared.
"What happened?" Matt asked lowly.
"I just can't, I just can't, I just fucking can't!" I got louder as I spoke.
"Did something happen with your dad?" I nodded slowly. Matt and I went inside closing the door.
"WHAT THE FUCK HAPPENED!" Matt seemed angry, not at me... but my Dad.
"W-we argued... for the first time, a-and it didn't end well." I say crying loudly, and barley able to hear what I was saying.
"Liv... you need to calm down I can barley tell what you're saying."
"I-I don't know wha- wha- why." I tried to speak but as I kept trying to spit it til... Matt pushed his lips onto mine. The kiss lasted only a few seconds but filled with so much passion.

"Matt... I-"
"Look, I'm sorry for doing that but you need to calm down." I nod.
"Sorry." I say.
"Don't be." I couldn't help myself, I kissed him again.
"Sorry." I say.
"You like me back?" He asked I nod.
"I've been trying to figure out my emotions for you and Chris for the past few days, and after the night you came over to check on me. The night you spilled your feelings, I completely fell for you. I lost all feelings for Chris that night as well." Matt smiled holding my hand dragging me upstairs.
"Tired?" Matt asked me.
"Very." I respond.
"Ok." We made it to his room. Matt gave me clean clothes.
"You might want to take a shower." I gave Matt a sweet smile before going into his bathroom.

I started the shower, making sure it was warm before going in. Just before I slip off my clothes I need to ask Matt something.
"Matt?"
"Matt's not in here right now." Chris says.
"Oh, well do you have anything that I can for body wash or shampoo?"
"Yeah, you can use my moms stuff. I'm sure she wouldn't mind."
"Ok thank you."
"Yeah, your welcome." Chris ran downstairs to get it. Once he came but I grabbed them rushing to the bathroom getting into the shower. It felt nice for warm water to hit my soft cold skin. I thought about what may happen in the future for me, since I don't live with my dad anymore.
I lathered my hair with the shampoo. The smell of coconut hit my nose. I sighed wondering what's gonna happen between me and Matt.

I got out the shower drying myself with the towel. I pulled up the sweats and throwing on the shirt Matt had given me. I found unused toothpaste and an unused toothbrush. I brushed my hair throwing it into a messy bun before leaving the bathroom. It was around 10pm, and I was pretty tired. I open the door to see Matt chilling on his phone. He looks over at me, making room for me in his bed.
"I can sleep on the floor if you're uncomfortable." I say.
"No, don't worry about it. Unless you're uncomfortable, then I'll sleep in a sleeping bag."
"No, I don't mind." He smiles turning to the other side so his back is facing me. To be honest I thought about this way more then it had to be. Matt faced me once again pulling me into his chest.

I woke up to me off the bed. What the hell happened last night? I got up to see the boys all in one bed.
"WHAT THE FUCK!" I woke them all up but I didn't care.
"Care to explain?" I ask putting my hands on my hips.
"I wanted cuddles." Chris says jokingly.
"I'm scared of the dark." Nick says as an excuse which was pretty shitty because I caught on fairly quick.
"I love my brothers." Matt said confidently.
"Wow, so you choose your brothers over me?" I say acting offended.
"Yep." Matt smiles stretching his arms up.
"I'm going to go make breakfast." I walk downstairs. To see Marylou, the triplets mom.

"Hi Mrs. Sturniolo." I smile in her direction.
"Oh hi! Matt told me everything last night... I'm so sorry." She comes over to hug me.
"Would you like any help?" I asked seeing as she's making breakfast.
"Yeah, if you'd like. You can set up the table, and I'll finish up the pancakes."
"Ok!" I set up the table as. I see all the boys come down.
"I smell pancakes!" Nick yells while trailing behind his brothers.
"Someone's excited." Marylou laughs.
"Morning." I say to Matt. His hair was messy, and his eyes just told me how tired he was.
"Morning." Matt says in his raspy morning voice. I hug him as he sneaks a kiss on my cheek luckily no one saw. Well till I looked over to see everything looking like they just saw a ghost. I'm in big trouble.

Chris's POV:
I felt heartbroken, I know that Olivia likes Matt and Matt likes Olivia but it still hurts.
"So this is why you two were cuddling in Matt's bed last night?" I say as tears got to the brim of my eyes.
"I thought we made a deal Liv." Nick sighs.

Olivia's POV:
"Boys, don't be like that. They're growing up you know." Marylou says, they nod and sit down. Me and Matt also sat down. Matt signaled for me to come closer to him. So I did.
"They'll forgive us at some point." Matt whispered.
"We aren't even dating this isn't fair." I whispered in his ear back.
"Couldn't agree more." He yet again whispered in my ear.
"Are we gonna keep whispering or are we gonna talk about what is happening between you two?" Chris asked.

Nick's POV:
"So." I say
"So." Matt answered.
"WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TWO TO EACH OTHER?!" Chris yells trying to get Olivia and Matt's answers. Why was Chris so mad anyways?
"Chris, calm down!" I say.
"YOU WANT ME, TO CALM DOWN? WHEN THESE TWO ASSHOLES HAVE BEEN DATING THIS WHOLE TIME!"
"WE AREN'T FUCKING DATING CHRIS!" Olivia yells. I've never seen her yell before... it honestly intimidated me.
"Guys! Just shut the hell up! Please!" Matt pleaded.
"No Matt. I'm fucking tired of your bullshit."
"Whatever." Matt walks off not eating anything.

"I should go." Olivia says.
"Yeah, you should." Chris bluntly suggests.
"Chris, what the fuck? I know you're mad but that was mean, don't you think?" I say.
"Yeah you're right. Sorry Liv." Chris opens his arms and Olivia smiles willingly embraces him.
"Sorry again for yelling at you I guess I was just-"
"Jealous?" Olivia says looking into his eyes, cutting him off.
"Yeah, I guess I was jealous."
"Woah, woah, woah, what?" I pitch in.
"That's a story for another time." Olivia tells me.