the two boys i fell in love with // m.s (2023)

Forgiving

Matt's POV:
I sighed being annoyed at Chris. I don't understand why Chris cares about a kiss he never even acted like he had feelings for Olivia. I walked downstairs seeing Chris Olivia and Nick on the couch watching a new movie that came 'missing' Chris slowly moved his arm onto Olivia's shoulder looking back at me smiling. Why is he such a bitch?
"What are u guys watching?" I ask as I walked over playing it off. I made space and sat in between Olivia and Chris I moved his arm and put mine over Olivia's shoulder looking back a Chris smirking. Olivia snuggled closer to me putting her head on my shoulder.

Olivia's POV from earlier:
Chris Nick and I decided to watch a movie I sat down next to Chris, but not close enough to be I heard footsteps but I didn't bother to look back. I felt an arm wrap around me. Chris was making me uncomfortable, but yet I stayed silent. Matt came over which gave me relief he removed Chris's arm and placed his instead. I pulled myself into Matt I felt comforted.

Chris's POV:
I know I'm being a complete dick, but i have this feeling were I can't see Olivia and Matt like that. God I've fucked up. I shouldn't have been such a asshole to Olivia my whole life.
"Matt." I say.
"Chris." He replied.
"That was fucking rude."
"I don't know, I think it's fucking rude to act like that when you've never even cared about Olivia little alone had a crush on her. You've always fucking hated her, so why all of a sudden care about her?"
"Matt... I-" Olivia tried speaking up but I interrupted with a quick reply.
"I've loved Olivia my whole fucking life. I just didn't want to hurt your fucking feelings by liking the same girl as you, so I shut everyone out just to try to lose my fucking feelings."
"That's bullshit, this whole situation is bullshit. I don't want to fight like fucking children such bullshit." Matt was heated I've never seen him at angry.

"Just shut the fuck up for once in your fucking life! You're making the poor girl uncomfortable by your behavior so fix this fucking problem you two have. If not then you guys can fuck yourselves you little fucking bitches. I'm sick of the ducking arguing all the fucking time. Save it for the fucking car videos. You bitches need to calm the fuck down before Olivia feels even more fucking uncomfortable about the shit you both have against each other." Damn, Nick usually likes to argue, but I guess this is pretty serious well it's a dumb reason to argue but a serious argument. Nick grabbed Olivia's wrist lightly taking her to someone upstairs. Matt sighed leaving the room also going upstairs.

I watched movie slowly falling asleep before my mom came in.
"Why is Olivia crying? Nick said it had something to do with you." My mom said.
"Me and Matt just got into a argument, and she uh... got uncomfortable so Nick stood up for her. Then brought her somewhere I have no idea where." She nods
"You should say sorry to your brother." My mom had said.
"Yeah, I guess so." I sighed getting up going upstairs to Matt.

Walking up the stairs I thought about how I felt. I know I should just let Matt and Liv do their thing, but it won't be as easy as it seems. I sighed walking into Matt's room. Matt and Olivia were all cuddled up watching something on Matt's phone. Matt twisted his finger in Olivia's hair I wanted to break them apart, but I didn't. I took a deep breath before talking.

"I'm sorry." Matt and Olivia look up.
"You should be." Olivia whispered something in Matt's ear, I furrowed my eyebrows trying to figure out what they were saying, but it didn't really puzzle all together.
"You know, me too." Matt got up pulling me into a hug which I quickly excepted. I heard loud footsteps from someone coming in. As I saw Nick come in he jumped up in down.
"No more fighting?!" Nick asked excitedly.
"I guess so." Matt answered. Nick quickly pulled us into a hug. Which me and Matt signaled for Olivia to join. Which she did. After a little Olivia had pulled away.
"I hate when you guys fight." She says lowly.
"Yeah, we know." We once again group hugged but not as long as the first.

Throughout the day we parted ways. I was hanging out with Nick, and Matt and Olivia were doing something. I know I'll be jealous for a bit, but I'll get over it at some point. I just want to see them happy so I'll support it.

"Chris, Chris? Earth to Chris!" Nick says awakening me from my day dream of thoughts.
"Huh?" I say confused.
"You good?" Nick asked.
"Mhm, just thinking."
"Don't overthink it, they aren't even dating." Nick tells me, and I just nod.

Olivia's POV:
Me and Matt were snuggled up watching movies for the majority of the time we spent together.
"Hey do you wanna go do something? Just us?" Matt asked me pausing the movie that was playing in front of us.
"Uh, yeah sure!" I replied getting up. I got up getting ready for what I see as a date. Matt said it was just us kind of making it seem like a date. I took deep breaths to why he would even want to take me out.
"I'm ready!" I call out.
"Ok, I'm down stairs!" I ran the stairs worried that I may fall.
"Jesus Liv, don't fall now!" I sorta laughed.
"So is this like, at date?" I had asked.
"Do you want it to be?" I shrugged.
"Well, I did plan it as a date, so I guess it is." We exited the house walking up to the minivan.
"Ladies first." Matt smiled opening the passenger seats door.
"What a gentleman." We both laugh, Matt ran to the other side hoping in it.
_________________________________
A/n:
Tysm for all the happy birthdays!
❤️❤️