Island of the Slaughtered

Day 21

The island was so big, that it'd took a day to find Noah. Just like all the other victims, (except Tyler and Sadie) they weren't found right away.
The group had actually passed his body a few times, thinking that it was Justin in the water because they had similar hair. "Since we can't find him, what if he's not dead? What if he's walking around trying to find us too?" Owen asked, full of hope. "That possibility is like 0.1%." Courtney replied. "STOP." Gwen screamed. "You know how we passed the "pond" that Justin was thrown into? Well that one didn't have a water fall behind it, and the other one did. We passed a lake." Everyone scrambled to retrace their steps and eventually found themselves at the lake they had passed several times. "That looks like Justin when we found him though?" Trent said, confused. "Oh my god, there's a knife sticking out of his shoulder!" Leshawna announced. "Did Justin have a knife in his shoulder?" Harold asked. "No..."
Present day: Chris just assumed that Justin was as eager to see him as he was. "Atleast they're alive." Alejandro said, reassuring Chris. They all stepped onto the island in unison, being careful to not run into the killer that Chris had seen before he left. "Okay, we don't have to be careful anymore. Since that guys obviously alive, it means nobody else died." Sierra said in a bored tone. "Yeahhh..Eva was here. Maybe she beat him up." Chris muttered. As soon as they stepped foot onto the island an animal jumped out of a bush and started attacking Chris. Alejandro swatted at it and as soon as he made touch with the animal, it shrieked and ran back to wherever it was. "What the hell?"
Day 21: This prompted Cody to run up to the lake, not caring that his pants were soaked. He flipped the body over and was met with Noah's face. Instead of saying anything, he just examined it. Looking at the red mark around his neck, and his white eyes. Owen could tell what this meant and went feral. He pounced at Duncan but was held back by Dj and Izzy. "I'm s-so sorry! I didn't know he would die I thought he would find his way back! Im sorry!" Duncan stuttered. Cody paid no mind to whatever was going on behind him, he just carried Noah's body onto land and set it in front of the group. Duncan was mortified. "Cody, I'm so sorry! Please I really am." Without saying a word he grabbed Duncan's head and turned it towards Noah. "LOOK WHAT YOU DID!" He yelled, before finally breaking down and hugging Owen. Izzy punched Duncan in the face. Courtney couldn't believe it. She tried to best to defend Duncan before, but now she couldn't even look him in the eye and this broke him the most. Geoff looked at him with disgust and walked away with Bridgette and everyone started to follow. "I can't even think how someone I thought was amazing and sweet could do this." Courtney grunted. "I didn't mean to kill him. I just wanted him to come back and learn that he can't always be sarcastic and a smartass. Just to scare him." He pleaded. "Well you scared him alright, imagine what he felt being drowned and stabbed in the shoulder!" She walked away and he had no choice but to follow and face everyone that night.