Don't Blink by the--blackdahlia (John Winchester X Reader)

Chapter 14

AN: Sorry the chapter is a little shorter. It's kinda filler lol

1989

After the hunt was done, they all returned to the motel. (Y/n) carried Sam in, his head on her shoulder as he slept. Dean rubbed at his eyes and held on to her shirt that thankfully Caleb had. It fit more like a dress, but it was better than walking around in John's coat and her underwear. (Y/n) tucked the boys in while John, Bobby, and Caleb took turns using the bathroom and cleaning up.

"Goodnight Dean." (Y/n) whispered, playing with his hair. He yawned and fell asleep quickly. Sam started to wake up as (Y/n) laid him down. "Goodnight Sammy."

"Night, night." Sam said before drifting back off. (Y/n) quietly left their room and walked over to the guys.

"Here are the couple things I had." John said. They were the t-shirt and sweatpants he had let her borrow all those years ago. She smiled and took them before heading to the bathroom. She showered as John told Caleb and Bobby about who she was.

"WHAT?!" She heard Bobby yell out as she pulled on the Marines t-shirt. She quickly ran out of the bathroom to have three sets of eyes on her.

"Shh, you'll wake the boys." John hissed.

"Why didn't you offer this piece of information sooner?" Bobby asked. "We could have found her and kept her safe or something."

"I didn't even know where she went." John said. "And I was scared that if I mentioned something, the demon would find her before I got a chance to." (Y/n) placed a hand on his shoulder, causing him to look up at her and smile.

"So...your Sammy's mom." Caleb said. "I see where he gets those dimples from." (Y/n) couldn't help but smile. John shot a look at Caleb.

"So, she's a time traveler?" Bobby asked. "I didn't think they existed."

"Neither did I." John said. "But Missouri would know if she was bad." He looked over at (Y/n), but he couldn't see anything wrong with her. But he saw a lot of things right.

"Are you going to break the news to Sammy?" Caleb asked. John sighed.

"Dean knows. But he knows how to keep a secret from his brother. I just...I don't know if I should cause that rift between him and Dean. Sam knows they're brothers, and he thinks Mary is his mom." He placed a hand on (Y/n)'s. "I don't want to hurt him by telling him I've lied to him about this."

"Mary is his mom. That's what he knows." (Y/n) said sadly. She walked back into the bathroom and shut the door, leaning against it. She tried to mute herself as tears fell down her face. She knew that Sam would never know she was his mom. She had been there in the future. Time travel was making her head hurt. There was a soft knock at the bathroom door then.

"(Y/n)?" John asked softly. "Caleb and Bobby left. Can you come out?" (Y/n) sighed and wiped her eyes before stepping out of the bathroom. But then minute she saw John's face, the tears came again. He pulled her to his chest, holding her close. "(Y/n)..."

"It's just hard." She whispered. "He's my son and I can't even tell him. I can't tell you guys what happens in the future because I could fuck up the timeline or something. Biff could end up as president or something..."

"One thing hasn't changed though." John said, tilting her head back so she could look up at him. "I still love you. And now that I know what is out there, I'm not letting you go. I'm going to protect you."

"John..." She whispered. He leaned down and kissed her, pulling her closer to his chest.

"We better use this time that the boys are asleep." John said with a wink. (Y/n) smiled and took his hand, following him to where his bed was.

****

Present

"Come on Sammy." Lucifer said, sitting on the edge of the bathtub. "You and I are like all the great couples in the universe. Chandler and Monica; Amy and Rory, John and (Y/n)." He smiled at Sam. "Everyone knows how your mommy and daddy's names were written in the stars. But some asshole brothers of mine decided that they didn't get to be happy."

"Why are you here?" Sam asked in a low voice. He didn't want Dean to know that Lucifer was talking to him.

"To tell you that everything my brothers are saying is right." Lucifer explained. "Maybe I can earn your trust then. I could show you how your lives would've been if they would've left your mom and dad in their right destiny line." Sam shook his head.

"I won't ever trust you." Sam growled. Lucifer just smiled.

"Never say never." He laughed. He stood up and walked towards Sam. "You will say yes to me eventually. So will one of your brothers. But if you want to know how royally screwed up my brothers made your life, then just should out oui!" With that, Lucifer was gone. Sam rubbed his eyes before he walked over towards the bathtub to start running the water. But there was one thing on his mind.

What had the angels done to them?