cuteness: 5/10
hotness: 6/10
age gap: 2/10 (same as knuxouge, but sonic is 15, rouge is 18. this could easily become a case)
friendly-ness: 8/10
rival-ness: 7/10
rouges part of the ship: 5/10
sonics part of the ship: 3/10
logic: 7.3/10
fan-art: 8/10
official art: 8.9/10
fan-made animations: 5.1/10
official animations: 8/10
other: i don't ship it, alongside knuxouge, this could easily make rouge a pedo, but hell, sonic gets all the women.
overall: 5/10