sturniolo/nate imagines 2

virgin?-nate

Nate POV

I rolled over and felt warm skin. My eyes snapped open as I remembered last night. Fuck, fuck. Fucking shit. Why did i do this? I slowly sat up and Y/N was still asleep. I carefully got up and got dressed. What do I do? The triplets can't know I fucked their sister. They'd kill me. But she was so good. Fuck, what is she gonna do? If she tells them I'm dead. I stared at her a while, thinking. Her eyes opened and I froze.
"Morning," she yawned, sitting up and holding the blanket to her chest.
"Hey," I mumbled nervously. "Um, so, about last night," I started, not knowing what to say.
"Ya, it meant nothing, I know." She nodded. I looked to her her in surprise.
"I, uh, ok." She got dressed as I tried not to look at her.
"Well, bye." She opened the door.
"Wait,"
"What?" She turned back.
"Uh, could you like, not,"
"I won't tell anyone." She said before I could finish. Oh.
"Bye." She left. What the fuck? She's just leaving? We barely even talked. I guess I should probably be happy. But it didn't really mean nothing to me. I guess it did to her.

(Time skip)

It's been 2 weeks since Y/N left me. That sounds dramatic, but she really did. I've thought about it a lot, and I like her. I mean i liked her before. But it's bad now. I can't stop thinking about her. But she's completely normal. She acts like nothing happened. Honestly, it hurts. I feel like a lousy one night stand.
Right now, I'm sitting at the triplets counter waiting for them to get home. Also, thinking about her. It's honestly sad. I need to get over it. The front door opened, and a pair of voices came through. What the fuck.
"Nate?" Y/N said as she saw me.
"Who's that?" I motioned to the guy next to her.
"Uh, this is Steve." She sighed, he gave an awkward wave.
"You're not supposed to have boys over."
"Why are you here?"
"I'm waiting for the triplets."
"They're not gonna be home for like an hour."
"I know."
"I can go..." Steve said, pointing to the door.
"No. Nate can go." She nodded, giving me a look.
"I'm not going anywhere."
"Nate, leave."
"No."
"It's my house."
"Then why is he here?"
"Because he was invited."
"I was invited."
"By people who aren't here. So leave."
"No."
"Really, I can go." He took a step back.
"You really should." I nodded.
"No. Stay." She grabbed his arm, pulling him back. I rolled my eyes.
"Nathan." She said firmly.
"How would the triplets react if I told them you snuck a boy over?" I crossed my arms.
"How would they react if I told them what you did with their sister?" I narrowed my eyes at her.
"Ya, I just gonna go.." He slowly walked back. She sighed and nodded.
"I'll call you." She nodded. He left.
"What the fuck?" She crossed her arms.
"What are you doing sneaking guys over like that?"
"I wasn't even sneaking."
"You should be thanking me. He only wanted one thing."
"I know."
"What?" My anger was replaced with confusion.
"Why do you think I brought him over when no one was home?" She said like it was obvious.
"But, why?"
"I can sleep with whoever I want."
"Don't do that, Y/N. You're gonna regret it."
"I'm not."
"You don't know that!"
"Well it's my life and you can't stop me!"
"I'll tell you're parents."
"I just wanted you to take my virginity! Not be a controlling dick!" She realized what she said and her eyes widened.
"Virginity? You were a fucking virgin?" I said in disbelief.
"Doesn't matter." She went to her room.
"That does fucking matter Y/N! Why didn't you tell me? God, i would've, I would've made it better, I would've,"
"It's fine."
"It's not fine! Fuck, I would've even done it if I knew!"
"I know! That's why i didn't tell you."
"You can't hide something like that Y/N."
"Why not?"
"I could've hurt you, or what if something went wrong, you just, you need to say stuff like that."
"Well it was fine." She shrugged, sitting on her bed.
"You should've told me."
"Sorry, just stop being mad." She sighed.
"Fine." I sat in front of her, taking a breath.
"Thank you."
"Why didn't you tell me?" I asked, wanting an explanation.
"I don't know, i just didn't want you to know." She said quietly, avoiding my eyes.
"Why not? I wouldn't have judged you."
"I know. But I didn't want you to make a big deal about it."
"It is a big deal." She just shrugged.
"Y/N, why would you even want that?"
"Well, i wanted to do it with other guys." She said, my anger crept back in.
"But i didn't wanna waste my first time on them, and I didn't really trust them enough. So I did it with you first so I wouldn't regret it with them." She explained.
"Y/N." I sighed. Why would she even do that.
"Sorry," she mumbled, playing with the edge of her blanket.
"I just don't get it. Why do it? And why me?"
"I was just sick of being a virgin. And I don't know, i like trust you, and you're hot." She shrugged, I smirked.
"You trust me, and I'm hot?"
"Ya,"
"Then why, not like, date me?" I asked nervously.
"What?" She looked up.
"You trust me, and are like attracted to me, doesn't that just mean...you have a crush on me?" I questioned, her cheeks turned pink, and I faintly smiled.
"N-no, that's not... no." Her blush deepened.
"You do." I smiled.
"Fine. I like you." She admitted.
"What about steve?" I asked, my smile faltering.
"What about him?"
"Aren't you guys like, together?" I asked, the words making me feel sick.
"No."
"Then why are you bringing him here, knowing what he wants?"
"I don't know, i don't have the guilt of losing my virginity to a random guy anymore, and I wanted to have fun."
"Ok," I sighed. That's extremely stupid, and I wanna yell at her for it. But, I don't wanna yell at her, ever. I wanna hold her and kiss her, and love her.
"So..." She smiled, scooching a bit closer. "I'm assuming you like me too." She said quietly, I nodded, staring at her pretty eyes.
"So, we both like each other....."
"Ya," I giggled. She raised her eyebrows, and I smiled.
"Ok, ok. Will you go out with me?" I asked hopefully.
"Yes!" She said excitedly. I replayed it in my head.
"I've been waiting for this since I was 14." She sighed.
"14?"
"Ya. When you were playing baseball and you smiled at me when you made it home, that's when i got it bad."
"I remember that." I smiled, "the triplets yelled at me for flirting with you."
"That wasn't flirting,"
"It totally was." I nodded. "And apparently, it worked. That's when you got the hots for me." I smirked.
"So about this date you're gonna take me on,"
"I'll take you anywhere you want." I tucked a piece of hair behind her ear.
"Disneyland?"
"Sure," I giggled, grabbing her hand.
"Ok." She kissed me, I froze for a second, then pulled her closer, melting into it. Mine.