Witches and Werwolves Don't Mix

Owe you one

~~~
Rachel POV
Finn drops me off in front of my houses gate. He looks so handsome here in the sunset dawning.

"Thanks, I um, owe you one" I say trying to shake his hand
"No need, it was my pleasure" he says in a bland tone

I just laugh, he looks confused

"Really? It was your pleasure to risk your life for me?" I smile confused at why he would do that for me.

He smiles

"Yes, it very much was" he says showing me his adorable dimples
"Well I guess I'll see ya around, Finn" I say sneaky
"It'd still be nice if I knew your name" he smirks trying to get it out of me
"It would, too bad you'll have to figure it out" I smirk back

Unfortunately our conversation is interrupted by my witchy friends. I groan because we were just getting to the good part, and they gave away my name.

"Rachel!" Quinn yelled waving with Brittany and Santana close behind

Finns smirk turns into a grin and he backs away smiling.

"See ya Rachel" he walks away

I just smile because now he knows
~~~
"Looks like rachie has a crush" Brittany sings out
"Do not" I say back
"Do too, I can hear your thoughts" Brittany sang back
"Damn your power" I squint at her linking our arms together
~~~
*next week
Santana POV
My power has grown a little bit. I mean I can set things on fire from a distance now. Rachel and Finn have been flirting all week, and it's super annoying. Like, seriously? We all now they like each other, Finn just needs to ask her out already. Quinn and I always make fun of her because we know her nana would never approve of Finn. I would never say this out loud but, I think her and Finn would make a great couple.

Quinn POV
A week has passed since Rachels nana taught us some tricks and I've gotten better at speaking to animals. After we saw Finn, we knew they liked each other, and what do you know we were right. They've been flirting with each other all week and like eye-loving each other. I don't think they think people notice, but they do. Seriously everyone thinks they should just date already. But I think Finns holding back, I can sense it, I don't know why though, maybe he just want to use her? But I feel like that's not his style. Whatever I'll let the two lovebirds handle there situation.
~~~
Rachel POV
It's been a week and Finn and I have gotten really flirty, I like it. My feelings toward him feel legit, but I don't want to get my heart broken. That's probably the only thing that I'm scared of happening. Plus I don't know if Finns a werewolf, I mean I don't think so. But he's the first guy I've encountered who I haven't put a spell on to check. I think I might actually like Finn more than a friend.

"Rachel!??" Santana yelled waving a hand in my face
"Huh? Oh sorry, what were you saying?" I ask confused
"We're going to go practice behind the bleachers, you coming?" Quinn asks
"Yeah I'll be there in a minute, let me just go to the bathroom" I say going into the girls bathroom
"Alright see ya B" Santana said walking off
~~~
I walk into the bathroom and check the stalls.....empty. Good I need a spell that can make me stop feeling these feelings. I can't have them, they're too dangerous, I don't even know who Finn is, but he is a good guy.......still, no exceptions, I don't have time for boys. I wash my face and stare at my reflection when I smell smoke. That's strange.