The walk back to the living room felt strangely like the walk of shame as Roman and especially Seth scrutinized our every move. I didn't miss the way Seth's eyes narrowed as he looked at Dean, who ran upstairs.
"Where's he going?" Roman asked.
"I don't know" I said as I sat back down in my spot
"So what did you get up too?" Roman asked
I picked up my beer and took a generous swig from it, hoping to avoid the question. The whole situation was embarrassing enough without having to explain it all. Plus, I was a little ashamed of how quickly I'd forgotten about who I was kissing and just gone with it. Drinking more alcohol wasn't helping, but it was a distraction.
"That's private" I eventually answered
Roman raised one of his eyebrows at me and looked over at Seth, who looked liked he'd just received the worst news of his life. I couldn't help but wonder if something had happened while I was gone to cause his change in mood, but before I could ask, Dean returned with what looked like a blindfold in his hand.
"Now the real fun can begin" Dean announced as he sat back down
I wasn't sure I even wanted to know what he was planning to do with a blindfold
"Yeah whatever, let's just get on with it" Seth mumbled from beside me
Dean spun the bottle, and it landed on Seth
"Right. Put this on Sethie boy" Dean said as he handed the blindfold to Seth.
"Why? What are you going to do?" Seth asked nervously.
"All three of us are going to kiss you and you have to guess which order we went in. If you guess correctly, then you can sit the next round out but if you guess wrong, then you have to do a dare of my choice" Dean explained
Seth huffed, but put the blindfold on. Dean motioned to Roman and me with his fingers, instructing Roman to go first, followed by me and then him
"Ready?"
Seth shifted uncomfortably. "Not really, but go ahead."
My mouth dropped open as Roman and Seth kissed. I was expecting a small peck on the lips, but this kiss was deep and lustful. I'd be lying to myself if I said that it didn't turn me on. Seth was eagerly kissing back, and I was wondering what I could do to top what Roman was doing. After another couple of seconds, Roman pulled back and turned to look at me, smiling as he mouthed the words beat that to me. I mouthed back, oh I will as I crawled over to Seth. I gently cupped his face with my hands; he jumped at the sudden contact and I had to fight back a giggle as I let my lips linger over his for a few seconds before lightly tugging on his bottom lip with my teeth. Seth let out a groan, and I slid my tongue into his mouth and kissed him. He instantly kissed me back, and I rested one of my hands on his chest, his rapid heart beat thumping against my hand. I kissed him for a while longer before eventually pulling back when I felt a little breathless. I sat back down and raised my eyebrow at Dean, silently challenging him as I finished the last of my beer. Dean moved to kneel in front of Seth and Roman and I watched as Dean placed a hand on the back of Seth's head and pulled his hair before he leaned in for a rough kiss. A slight groan escaped from Seth's lips as he kissed Dean back. Damn. Now this I could get behind, I thought as I enjoyed the scene in front of me. Maybe this game wasn't so bad after all.
"Right'' Dean said as he stood up and made his way back to where he was sitting. ''What order did we go in?"
Seth removed the blindfold, looking more than a little flushed. "Well, the first and third were definitely you and Roman, because I could feel your facial hair. Which means Jaime was second''
"But which one of us went first?" Dean asked with a sly smile
"Geez I don't know" Seth replied
"Just guess" I said with an encouraging smile
"Dean first and Roman last?" Seth said, unsure
"That's the wrong answer my friend" Dean replied triumphantly
Seth let out a disgruntled moan, and he raised his hands up in the air in defeat. "Come on then. Do your worst"
"I dare you to..." Dean said as he stroked his chin
I could almost see the cogs turning in his head, and I hoped he didn't embarrass Seth too much. He was easily the most sensitive out of all of us (even though he didn't like to show it) and I could already tell that he was feeling uncomfortable.
"I dare you to unhook Jaime's bra and remove it from her body using just one hand" Dean ordered proudly
It was becoming obvious to me that this whole game had now turned into Dean's own little version of who would give up first, and I was wondering if I should just call it a night once and for all and try to get some sleep.
"Oh, come on, man. That's too much" Roman stated.
"What are you talking about? I'm just getting started" Dean replied defiantly
"Look. I'm gonna call it a night" Roman said as he stood up. ''I'll see y'all in the morning"
''Night Ro'' I said as Seth gave him a friendly smile
"Well, somebody's a killjoy" Dean yelled as Roman disappeared upstairs
Seth looked at me with a troubled expression, obviously not wanting to carry out Dean's dare
"It's fine Seth. Let's just get it over with" I assured as I motioned for him to come closer.
His hand was shaking slightly as he reached underneath my shirt and I jumped as I felt his cold hand on my skin. I glared at Dean as Seth unclasped my bra and pulled it down. I helped him a little by wriggling my arms out of the straps.
"Happy now?" Seth asked as he held my bra out in front of him.
"For now" Dean answered
I excused myself to go to the bathroom. I needed a few minutes to get my head straight. This was quickly getting out of hand.
* * *
Seth
I couldn't help but wonder what Dean was trying to achieve with this game. He was obviously planning something, and I was going to find out what it was.
"What are you up to, Ambrose?" I asked once Jaime was out of earshot.
"What makes you think I'm up to anything?" he replied as he took a swig of his beer
"Because I know you and I can tell" I pointed out
"Ok so maybe I've got a plan, but it's only because I've developed an interest for a certain mutual friend of ours" Dean admitted
"You mean Jaime?" I asked "Since when?"
"Oh, since about half an hour ago when we made out" Dean replied
YOU ARE READING
Spin The Bottle
FanfictionIt's just a bit of fun, what harm can it do? After all it's only Spin the Bottle. That was exactly what Jaime thought as she played a unique game of Spin the Bottle with her three male friends but what she didn't realize was that it would lead to h...
