Secret Lover(s)

Chapter 4

"You've got to tell them," Bobby says angrily, "I told you to choose one of them, not add another one to the harem you've got going." Bobby found out about you and Cas when he came home earlier than expected one day. Needless to say, he was not happy when he found out. Ever since then, he'd been nagging you about making a choice. You neglected to tell him about the whole 'true mate' situation with Cas because you knew what he would say. You knew he would tell you to chose Cas and let Sam and Dean go. Maybe he was right, but you couldn't bring yourself to do it.

"Bobby, please, you don't understand," you beg as you pack your bag. Sam and Dean were on their way to pick you up for a hunt. You hadn't planned on going at first, but after you found out killing demons was involved, you jumped at the chance to go. Even though you had no clue why those demons had killed your family, you wanted to kill every last demon you could get your hands on. Your current situation with Bobby only made you want to get out of the house even more.

"I don't understand?" Bobby asks, "I think it's you that don't understand. Now you've got three people thinkin' you're in love with them."

"I am," you say helplessly, "I'm in love with all three of them."

"You know this isn't healthy right?" Bobby asks, "I see how you worry about them constantly while they're away. If you don't choose one you'll wear yourself out worrying about them all."

"Bobby, do you honestly think that choosing one would make me stop worrying about the others?" you ask, "Sam and Dean are like sons to you right? Could you choose a favorite if you had to?"

"The thing is, I don't have to," Bobby retorts, "I ain't sleeping with them and another man to boot."

"But let's say you chose Dean as your favorite," you say, "Would you stop caring about what happens to Sam?"

"That's not the point," Bobby argues.

"It is the point," you respond, "Even if I choose one, I'll still love the others."

"What about when they find out?" he asks, "You think that's going to go over well?"

"I don't know," you say. Thankfully, you hear the roar of the Impala as it pulls up to the house. You grab your bag and head towards the front door. Bobby follows after you.

"You can't keep this going forever, you realize that right?" he asks, "At some point, they're going to find out and they aren't going to be happy about it."

"I'll cross that bridge when I come to it," you respond, "Or maybe I'll just burn it."

Bobby reaches out and hugs you. "Whatever you do, be safe," Bobby says. You roll your eyes, but you hug him back. If there's one thing you don't want to do, its leave a friend on bad terms.

You rush to the car and hop into the back seat before Sam or Dean even have a chance to get out. Your bag gets tossed on the seat beside you. Dean turns around and hugs you, his arms wrapping tightly around your body. Sam turns and hugs you as soon as Dean lets you go, his hug lasts longer than it probably should in front of his brother. Bobby stays by the doorway, arms crossed and eyes narrowed.

"Hey Y/N," Dean says as he looks out the window, "What's up with Bobby?"

"We got into a fight," you respond.

"What about?" Sam asks.

"He doesn't think I'm ready to go on this hunt," you respond. It's not exactly false. Bobby had been training you, but he still hadn't taken you on any big hunts yet. He said you didn't have enough training to prepare you for all the crap that was out there.

Dean nods in understanding before he rolls down the window. "Don't worry Bobby, we'll take good care of her!" Dean shouts. He turns the car back on and waves as he pulls away from the house. Bobby just glares at you until you're out of view.