To Be Torn Between Two

Chapter 12: I Lost

Randy followed Kelly out of the room, needing to talk to the blonde about his feelings. "Kelly!" he called after her. "Kelly, wait!" When manged to catch up to her, he gently grabbed her arm and spun her round.

"I don't have anything to say to you, Randy" Kelly stated as she looked away from him.

"Ok, can I talk?" Randy asked, as Kelly pulled her arm away from him and consequently folded her arms across her chest.

"I never meant to hurt you" he started, "and I know I did the wrong thing."

"The wrong thing?" Kelly exclaimed exasperatingly. "You did more than just the wrong thing" Kelly snapped. "I told you I loved you and you said that I was your friend and that's all we could be, friends. How am I supposed to feel, Randy? You led me on."

"Oh I led you on, did I?" Randy fired back. "Is that why I went to check up on you after you're fight with Eve? No Kelly I did that because I love you." Randy pinched his nose in frustration. "I told you I loved you and that I made a mistake and you just pushed me away, like I don't even matter to you" Randy said but Kelly could hear how hurt he was. "I even left Eve for you, isn't that want you wanted?"

"I know" Kelly began fidgeting with her fingers. "I didn't know what to do, or what to say..." She did want Randy to leave Eve but she didn't want to answer the question because she was so confused about her feelings towards Randy and towards John. She had unexpectedly fallen for John and was unsure of what to do.

"You could have said 'I love you too', that would have worked" Randy stated, frustration finally overtaking him. Why couldn't Kelly understand his point of view? He just didn't want to hurt her but he ended up doing so because he made a mistake. A mistake. A silence fell between them before Randy met Kelly's light blue eyes. "Unless you don't love me and you love someone else."

"Is that what you think this is about?" Kelly exclaimed. "Randy this about you messing with my heart, nothing more, nothing less."

"And now you're messing with my heart, by going on a date with John. Yeah the pleasure of my name being next to Layla's on your phone..." Randy muttered, taking his phone out of his pocket and showing Kelly the text message as proof.

"Oh shit..." Kelly mumbled, tears becoming evident in her eyes. Silently, she cursed herself for not being careful when sending her text message to Layla. "Randy I-"

"Kelly, save it. I knew you and John were screwing around with each other " he stated, hurt becoming evident in his voice as he shoved his phone back into his pocket.

"Woah, woah... Kelly and I aren't screwing around with each other." John had heard an argument escalate in the hallway from his room, so he had decided to try and calm both the people down. Little did he know it was Randy and Kelly having the argument.

"Jesus Christ!" Randy exclaimed as he flung his hands up in the air. "Of course you're here right now. Kelly doesn't need you're help, alright?"

"I didn't say she did" John replied, raising his hands in mock surrender.

"You know, I think I'm done here" Kelly said as brushed past both of the Superstars. John watched as Kelly disappeared down the hallway and into the elevator. Randy sighed in frustration but deep inside he was hurting. How could Kelly go on a date with John after everything he had given up for her? Randy didn't understand her actions at all.

"What the hell did you do?" John asked, glaring at Randy.

"Excuse me?" Randy asked, raising his eyebrows in disbelief.

"What-did-you-do?" John repeated emphasizing each word with anger that had suddenly surged through him.

"This is none of your business Cena" Randy spat.