To Be Torn Between Two

Chapter 15: The Accident

Everything happened in slow motion. When Randy had kissed her, her heartbeat stopped. Sure, Randy had kissed her once before but this was completely different. This time Randy hadn't kissed her out of confusion. This time he truly meant it. This time it was everything she could have wanted. The touch of his lips and the emotions that touch made her feel was as if she was in heaven. That was the best way she could describe it. Then she remembered John, that he was her boyfriend now. John didn't deserve to see this and neither did Eve. John deserved a chance because all he seems to do is care for her and Randy was the complete opposite. All he does is break her heart and probably will continue to do so.

With that last thought, Kelly pushed him away, much to his surprise. Then without any warning, John had grabbed him by the collar of his shirt and threw him to the floor. Randy found himself disorientated as John threw a hard punch at his face. Everyone was silent. No one dared to move. Everyone was just standing there watching John pummel Randy. Cody who came to his senses pulled John off Randy and restrained him.

"John that's enough!" Cody yelled as he did his best to restrain John, who was now absolutely livid. Randy wiped at his mouth with the back of his hand. He knew he had a busted lip because of the salty taste that had invaded his mouth. Layla was the first to approach Randy, in order to help him up. He whispered a 'thanks' to her before turning his attention to Eve who was sobbing into Punk's chest. Punk wore a look of disdain upon his face as he shook his head disapprovingly at Randy. How could Randy possibly kiss Kelly in front of his ex-girlfriend? The man is a conceited asshole Punk thought, angrily. Pulling out of Punk's embrace, Eve finally turned to Randy, endless amounts of tears streaming down her face.

"How dare you Randy!" she screamed. "How dare you! How dare you!" She slapped him, not only once but twice. Randy didn't even bother to stop her because he knew he deserved everything he got from her. Eve then turned to Kelly, the look on her face was one of hatred and loathing.

"Eve I-"

"Save it Kelly! Save it for someone who cares!" Eve screamed before shaking her head at the blonde and storming out of the room.

"Eve!" Kelly called after her. "Eve, wait!" She was about to chase after her ex-best friend when Punk grabbed her by the arm, stopping her dead in her tracks.

"I think you've done enough, don't you think?" Punk spat before he hurriedly left the room in search for the brunette Diva. Then finally Randy and Kelly's gazes met.

"Kelly-"

"We need to talk Randy" she said, blinking away the tears as she walked into the bathroom, the only place they could get some privacy. Randy followed her. Then John, who was still fuming from earlier also turned to follow the duo, however, Cody and Layla both stopped him.

"They need to talk John. It's about time they work this out" Layla stated.

Randy closed and locked the door behind them as he watched Kelly grab onto the counter. Her head was bowed low and her shoulders were shaking. That was when Randy realized she was crying again.

"What are you doing Randy?" she asked in a voice that was almost painful to hear. "Why are you doing this to me Randy? Why can't you let me be happy? Why are you destroying everything John's trying to do for me? Why Randy? Why now? Why in front of John and in front of Eve? Have you lost your mind? What the hell are you trying to prove?"

"Kelly" he said, hurriedly walking over towards and attempting to pull her into a hug causing Kelly to struggle against his grasp. "Kelly, stop. Kelly!" He raised his voice, then silently cursed himself for doing so. "Please, just listen to me" Kelly stopped moving but continued to cry. "I am jealous of John. I am jealous of Phil because both of them have the girls that I love. But the thing is Kelly, I made a choice between you and Eve, not so along ago. I chose you but it was obviously too late. I don't regret making that choice, I don't regret anything." Kelly was still silent, not wanting to say anything. "With that being said I can't help but feel possessive of you, Kel. I feel something special for you and I know what that feeling is. It's love."