Sting or Natsu?

Mixed Feelings

Natsu let go of Lucy's arms and wrapping them around her waist to pull her more onto his lips. Once Lucy's arm was free, she wrapped both of her arms around his neck, wishing the kiss would last forever. They stood there for a few minutes until one of them finally broke the kiss. Natsu and Lucy starred at each other, blushing covering their cheeks. Awkward silence filled the room, until Lucy broke it.

"I um.."

"S-Sorry, Luce. I got caught in the mo-" Natsu began to say in embarrassment, but was interrupted.

"Don't worry." Lucy looked down, unwrapping her arms from around Natsu. She quickly glanced at Natsu to show a soft, sweet smile then turned around, his grip breaking from her waist. She yawned and raised her arms in the air stretching. "It's really late. We should go to bed.."

Natsu's cheek were still beaming with a dark shade of red then quickly nodded. "Mhm.." Natsu let himself drop onto the floor, his face landing on the pillow Before Lucy knew, he was fast asleep. She turned around and looked at him. Her lips formed a soft smile across her face as she grabbed the blanket and gently covered Natsu. 'Sweet dreams, Natsu..' And with that, Lucy laid on her bed and quickly fell asleep as well.

The next morning, Lucy woke up to find that everything where Natsu had slept was cleaned up. There were no pillows, no blankets, nothing. Not even Natsu. Lucy stood up from her bed, checked the bathroom then the kitchen only to find that everything was how it was last night, all clean. 

"I guess he left," Lucy said to herself as she shrugged. She grabbed 2 towels then walked into the bathroom to take a bath.

By the time she got out, she was cautious just in case anyone had broken into her house again, like always. Once she realized no one had broken in, she let her hair out of her towel and let both of her towels drop beginning to get dressed. 

The minute Lucy finished getting dress, she walked to her mirror picking up her blonde hair in a side pony tail when the door was suddenly slammed open. The young mage was startled and turned around only to find her best friends had broken into her house.

"Hey, Lucy!" The blue cat flew into the room with a big smile on his face. 

"Can't you guys knock!?" Lucy quickly finished picking up her hair then watched as both of her best friends walked into her apartment.

Natsu also had a big smile on his, "Hey Luce," he yelled and waved walking in. 

Happy flew up to Lucy and showed her a paper that read 'Help Wanted'. 

"We're going on another mission. Wanna come with us?" 

Lucy quickly scanned the flyer then looked at the blue cat who was still holding it. She nodded in agreement and watched as Natsu and Happy began to head out the door. A smile formed across her face then she quickly grabbed her bag and followed them out the door locking her apartment. 

"I'm so tired!" The door to Lucy's apartment was opened after unlocking it and in stepped the celestial wizard as she turned, her back facing her bed and she plopped down letting out a sigh in exhaustion. Natsu and Happy had gone home after dropping Lucy off at her apartment. The young blonde began to close her eyes until she heard a knock on the door. She opened her eyes and lifted her head slightly off the bed to look at the door then stood up placing her bag on the chair she passed by heading to the door. She wrapped her hand around the doorknob and gently pulled to reveal who was on the other side of the door. 

Lucy peaked slightly, "Oh!" She opened the door a bit wider and let the person in. She smiled, a light shade of red slowly appearing on her cheeks as she shut the door closed then turned to face the person. "What brings you here at this hour," She asked politely. 

"I need a reason to come see my girlfriend, now?" Sting faced Lucy, his eyes focused on her, his hands in his pocket. 

"No, but it's late," Lucy replied, trying hard not to sound rude. 

Sting pulled his hands out of his pocket and slowly walked towards Lucy. She walked backwards until her back leaned against the door. Sting placed his hands on the wall, his arm on each end of Lucy's shoulders leaving her trapped. 

"You're not going to kick me out, are you?" Sting's voice had began to sound low as he attempted to sweet talk her. "You don't mind if I'm here, do you?" His lips formed a small smirk across his face and he leaned in closer to Lucy's lips. 

Lucy gulped as quiet and softly as she could. "N-No," she stuttered as her heart began to race and Sting got closer and closer. 

Sting's smirk was wiped from his face as he laid his eyes on Lucy's lips then gently placed  is on hers. Lucy closed her eyes as she began to get the same feeling as when her and Natsu had kissed. The celestial mage raised her hand to place it on her boyfriend's cheek as their lips were glued together. Sting's own hand slowly made it's way down to her hip, leaving it there. 

Time seemed to be moving slowly, to Lucy, the kiss must have lasted ages. Their lips continued to stick together as they held the kiss. Lucy suddenly opened her eyes and spotting the window as it revealed how dark it now was outside. She turned her head to the side, her cheek now leaning on the door breaking the kiss. Her the palm of her hand was resting on the door by her side once again. Sting removed his hand from her hips and looked at her in a bit of confusion. 

"I-It's really late now, Sting. Shouldn't you go back home? You're friends must be worried about you." Lucy tried not to sound rude, but failed miserably. 

Sting stood up correctly, stuffing his hands back inside his pockets and looked at Lucy, a small smirk across his face once again. "Eh. You're right." He smiled and gently placed his lips on her cheeking leaving a small kiss then removed his lips. 

Lucy blushed super red, her other cheek still leaning on the door. Her lips shined a very soft, shy, gentle smile.

"Um, Lucy?" Sting starred at her, his smirk faded.

Lucy turned her head to look at him, "Hm?"

"The door."

"O-Oh, right," Lucy blushed even more in embarrassment then stood up correctly leaning off the door and moved to the side a little letting Sting open the door and walk out. "Goodnight," She said softly as she watched Sting walk out the door. 

Lucy shut the door and let herself drop on her bed letting out a long sigh. Her cheeks were as red as a rose, as she continued to think about what just had happened. After a few minutes she stood up, changed into her pajamas and made her way back to her bed. Her cheeks were still blushing before she fell asleep. She couldn't stop thinking about Sting until she remembered the night before with Natsu. 

"Oh no. What am I going to do? Do I really have to choose between them two?" Lucy began to say to herself as she realized that she had feelings for both guys. 

There she laid awake in confusion. Until she finally tired herself out and fell asleep.