Keeping Secrets

Broken hearted

Lexi's POV

I'm walking around backstage waiting for John. He says he has a surprise for me. I'm really happy and nervous at the same time and I don't know why. I walked past one of the locker rooms and heard arguing. This is Phil's locker room! I knock on the door and Phil answers it looking super pissed off. I walk by him and into the locker room to find Kaitlyn on the ground crying. "WHATS GOING ON!"

Johns POV

I walk out of the jewelry store with the little box in my hand. I run over to my car so I can go and meet Lexi at the stadium.

Lexi's POV

I wait for Phil to answer. He has tears in his eyes and he finally answers. "Your friend Kaitlyn over there went and...and." Phil fell to the ground crying, I ran over to him and hugged him tightly. "And what Phil?" He sniffled before speaking. "She fell in love with someone else." I was beyond shocked. I thought they would be together forever. "Kaitlyn why? I thought you were in love with Phil." "I was but then I started thinking about this one person and how kind and thoughtful he is." "Who is it?" "I...I..c-can't tell y-you." "Why not?" Phil spoke up this time. "FOR GOODNESS SAKE JUST TELL HER WHO IT IS!" "Ok fine it's..." She took a deep breath and said softly. "It's John...im in love with John."

"YOURE IN LOVE WITH MY BOYFRIEND!"

Johns POV

I finally got to the arena and went to my locker room. Lexi wasn't there so I figured she's at Phil's talking to Kaitlyn. I walked over to where Phil's room is and heard a lot of yelling. What's going on?

Lexi's POV

"ARE YOU EVEN MY FRIEND KAITLYN OR WERE YOU JUST TRYING TO GET CLOSER TO JOHN!" "WERE YOU GOING TO TRY AND STEAL HIM AWAY FROM M-..." I was cut off because Phil turned me around. I looked into his sad eyes and waited for him to start yelling at me. But instead he just stood there looking back at me. Then out of nowhere his lips were on mine. It felt wrong because I'm dating John, but for some strange reason it felt right! I kissed back passionately. I didn't have a care in the world.

Phil's POV

I KISSED LEXI! BUT SHES DATING JOHN, MY FRIEND! At first I was just going to kiss her to make Kaitlyn jealous but now...it feels like something more. Is this wrong for me to do? But right now it feels like were the only people in the world. This kiss is WAY MORE than just the little spark me and Kaitlyn had. No...this feels like the fourth of July. Like a million fireworks!

Johns POV

I heard Lexi's voice but then she got cut off it was silent. I waited a few seconds then decided to walk into the room. But now I wish I didn't. Lexi and Phil were kissing passionately. I swallowed the huge lump in my throat and decided to speak up. "Are you two done yet!"

Lexi's POV

"Are you two done yet!" I knew that voice it was Johns. Phil and I jumped apart. I looked up at John. But before I could say anything Phil spoke up. "John...its not what it looks like." Then John spoke. "It LOOKS like you were kissing my ex girlfriend!" "EX?" "Yes...Lexi it's over were done." John stormed off while I fell to the ground with tears in my eyes. I heard Phil say something through my sobs.

Phil's POV

"KAITLYN GET OUT NOW!" I crouched down to Lexi while Kaitlyn walked out the room. "Lexi are you ok? How about since we both don't have matches tonight you can come stay with me at the hotel till tomorrow." She nodded her head yes, so I picked her up and brought her to my car.

Johns POV

I got in my car and drove down to the lake near by. Tears were blurring my vision. I took the diamond ring out of my pocket and collapsed to the ground crying. It took a while but soon I stopped crying a little. I looked at the ring one last time before throwing it deep into the lake. I went back to my car and back to the arena.

Phil's POV

Lexi and I arrived at the hotel. Shes crying on the couch right now. I sit down next to her. "Lexi are you ok." "Yea I feel a little bit better." She tries to fake a smile. "Look...I'm sorry I put you in this mess. If I hadn't kissed you...you wouldn't be crying right now." I felt tears forming in my eyes so I got up. I started to walk away but she grabbed my arm and pulled me back next to her. "Phil you might have kissed me first but I kissed you back...I wouldn't have done that if I didn't feel something for you." I felt myself blush...I never blush I'm supposed to be this loveable jerk that doesn't give a fuck if I hurt peoples feelings or not...and now I'm sitting here apologizing and blushing.

Lexis POV

Phil is blushing. Does he like me or something? He looked into my eyes. We both leaned in. Then that feeling of fireworks were back again when our lips touched. I smiled into the kiss before getting up. "Where are you going? "To sleep." "Ok." Phil got up and we both went to go to sleep. Phil held me in his arms. I smiled and soon I was asleep.

AJs POV

I was getting ready for my match when I heard a knock on the door. I was shocked to see John at the door. He had tears in his eyes. "Look Aj I know you were in a relationship with Sheamus." I was shocked how did he know. "But that's ok." "John I'm sorry I cheated on you I'm not even with him anymore. I love you. Will you forgive me?" "Of course." We both smiled. He gave me a quick kiss before I left for my match. I'm glad I'm back together with John.

Authors note

Does punk like lexi? Should lexi be with punk or john? How'd you like this chapter? Vote and comment :)