Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

Nicknames

A/N: So I'm making these ahead of time and this one is going to be really short.

Jeff the killer
You call him: My killer~
He calls you: Sweetheart~
You only allow him to call you sweetheart or they die! You called him your killer and it kinda stuck.

BEN Drowned
You call him: Babe
He calls you: Baby
You two just do it (hehe) it's just normal for you two.

Eyeless Jack
You call him: Heart Throb
He calls you: Sunshine
You call him Heart Throb because he makes you feel like you have a heart again. (Aww💓) He calls you Sunshine because you brought light into his dark world. (Cheesy I know but it's adorable)

Dark Link
You call him: My Knight
He calls you: Princess
I think it's obvious....

Laughing Jack
You call him: Mr. Giggles
He calls you: Gumdrop
You call him Mr. Giggles because he laughs all the time. He calls you Gumdrop because your so sweet.

Dr. Smiley
You call him: Doctor
He calls you: Nurse
This was something you decided to call each other, though your creepypasta name is Nurse so idk.

Homicidal Lui
You call Lui+sully(you) : Sweetie
You call Sully+lui(Naya) : Tiger
He calls you+naya(Lui) : Pretty Lady
He calls Naya+You (Sully) : Hot Stuff
Naya and Sully are super flirty and you and Lui are more polite.

Masky
You call him: Sugar Lips
He calls you: Dream Girl
You call him sugar lips because is lips are always sweet from cheesecake and he calls you Dream Girl because he swears he had dreams of you before you even met.

Hoodie
You call him: Shy Guy
He calls you: Lamb
You call him Shy Guy because he's your shy guy. He calls you Lamb because when you first met you were as quiet as a lamb.

Ticci Toby
You call him: Waffle
He calls you: Pancake
Again pretty obvious.....

Slenderman
You call him: My Gentleman
He calls you: My Lady
You call him your Gentleman because he's so polite. He calls you his Lady because he wouldn't be gentlemanly if didn't treat you like a lady.

Offenderman
You call him: Smexy
He calls you: Lover
You know why, the very first time you met you decided your fate.

Trenderman
You call him: My Quirky Boy
He calls you: Dove
You call him your Quirky Boy because he's different, but he's yours. He calls you Dove because he feels your graceful and fragile, but independent making you the most beautiful woman who ever lived. (awwww!)

Splendorman
You call him: Sprinkles (wahh! Sprinkles! Anybody? Aphmau?)
He calls you: Cupcake
You call him Sprinkles because he's colorful and sweet. He calls you Cupcake because you are sweet (and eat cake made of people muhaha), but he usually calls you your creepypasta name, Dollie.

Tenderman
You call him: Beloved
He calls you: Precious
You call him Beloved because he is your most beloved person. He calls you Precious because your his everything.

Zalgo
You call him: My King or God
​​​​​He calls you: My Queen or Goddess
You two like being called those things, you know because your God like creatures or maybe even God.

A/N: Wooo undertale music! Bye love you my little freaks 💓👋😸