Supernatural Preferences

Part 23 - He Asks You Out

-Dean

Dean and you went out one night for supper, just the two of you. You thought it wouldn't be awkward but boy, were you wrong. Dean complimented you, your hair, eyes, outfit.. But the one compliment that you like the most was when he complimented your smile.

"Thanks Dean." You said, your cheeks turning a light shade of pink. Dean only smiled in response.

Once your order was ready, you both started to eat. You took your usual, but being precaution of how you ate. "You know," Dean started to say, taking a big bite of his bacon cheeseburger. "I like a woman who can eat." He states, mouth full. You couldn't help but giggle. "Oh really?" You questioned, dipping one of your many fries on your plate into ketchup and taking a bite. Dean only nodded, not wanting to speak with his mouth full anymore.

The rest of the meal was quiet. Only a few exchanged words here and there. After any attempts of you trying to pay and many times Dean refused, you finally gave up and crossed your arms.

"C'mon Y/N, I always pay for your meals, so what's different about tonight?" He asks as you both get in the impala. You bit your lower lip and peered over at him. "I don't know.. It's just the two of us now, I don't want to make it seem like a.. Like a date." You finally mumble, turning your head and looking out the window.

"Well what if this was a date?" Dean asks, making you quickly turn your head and stare at him. "Y/N, I really wanted to ask you this for a long time but I finally did it right, would you be my girlfriend?" He asks, observing you, waiting for a reaction. Your cheeks darkened to a shade of red and you bit down on your lip. "I'd like that very much Dean Winchester." You finally manage to say. You leaned over and kisses his cheek.

You could say that you fell asleep that night in his arms with a smile plastered on your lips.

-Sam

Sam and you had the day off. So typically you wanted to go to the beach, you hadn't been there in ages and wanted to feel the sand between your toes, or the waves hit at your knees.

The brothers and you got changed and were now in the impala on the way to the nearest beach.

Once there you you placed your towel on the sand and began to take off your shirt and short, leaving you in a nice bright orange and yellow bikini.

When the the boys came over they looked you up and down, Dean smirked but Sam on the other hand had a shy smile and his cheeks turned a light shade of pink.

You always had a thing for Sam. You couldn't pinpoint why, maybe the fact that he was tall, his dimples, his smile, eyes or maybe it was the fact that he was intelligent. Heck, might be for all those reasons. You were getting kinda shy with the boys staring so you just sat down and took a book out from your bag and began to read.

"You seriously did not come to the beach just to read did you?" Sam asked, sitting down next to you. You glanced up from your book and nodded. "Why not? It's not like I can read with you guys around at Bobby's house and with all of his phones ringing." You reply. Sam just shrugged and took off his shirt, leaving him in his trunks. Dean had gone off to flirt with some girls, so it had left you alone with Sam.

After an hour or so of reading, Sam started to complain, telling you to stop reading. It wasn't until he took your book from your hands that you looked up at him. "Samm!!" You whined. "I was just at the good part." You say with a pout.

"Well read it later." He said, picking up your bookmark, placing it and closing the book throwing it in your beach bag.

Suddenly Sam had you in his arms, walking towards the ocean. After so far how he finally placed you down, the water reaching up under your breasts. "Now what?" You ask, glancing up at him. He only turned you making you face the horizon. You gasped.

"It's so gorgeous!" You exclaimed. You hadn't even realized it was this late. But the view of the sunset was absolutely amazing. Sam had wrapped his arms around you, pulling you back against his chest. He laid his head on yours and mumbled. "Y/N, the sunset might be a gorgeous view for you but you're mine." You were shocked by his words and blushed. "Be my girlfriend?" He suddenly asks, looking down at you. You glanced up and kissed him softly. "I'd love too Sam." You smile.

However the moment was ruined when water splashed the both of you. Sam glanced to where it came from and seen Dean laughing. Let's just say, you both got him back for it.

-Castiel

It had been a while since you had met Cas. However you both connected instantly. Becoming good friends. Sometimes you'd wish he'd be more then a friend.

One night when when you couldn't sleep, you got out of bed and crept your way downstairs and outside on Bobby's porch. Sitting on the railing you heard the familiar swoosh of wings, making you glance sideways only to find Cas looking at you with concern.

"Why aren't you asleep Y/N?" He asks. You smiled a little and looked up at the sky. "I couldn't sleep Cas." Was your reply to the angel. Castiel simply nodded and placed his trench coat around your shoulders. He noticed you were only in a small pair of shorts with a matching tank top. You peered at him.

"I don't want you to catch cold." Was all the angel said. "Thanks Cas." You said leaning over and gave him a gentle kiss on his cheek. Castiel smiled at the action and reacted by wrapping his arms around your waist, letting you lay your head against his chest.

"Y/N?" He suddenly says. "Yes Cas?" You said, eyes slowly closing. "Dean explained to me once that if someone loves somebody else they ask them to be their girlfriend or boyfriend." He started. "I don't quite understand the concept of it but I would like for you to be my girlfriend." He mumbles against your hair. "Cas, that's sweet of you, I'd love that." You say, snuggling into his chest more.

The next thing you knew, you were laying down in your bed underneath the covers, cuddled into Castiel's chest with him humming gently to Crazy Love.