Worst Moments in Percy Jackson Fanfictions

11

~ Nico sees reborn Bianca and she remembers him, and he somehow knows that she's Bianca (Percabeth2006)

No. Just no. How does this even?? No.

Bianca wouldn't remember him if she was reborn into a new life, and it would be impossible for Nico to recognise that it was Bianca he saw.

~ Calypso (KatnissTomlinstyles)

Where she @??? Apparently, Leo just left her and wanted to get together with the OC instead.

No. That doesn't even

Clearly Leo loves Calypso. I don't care if you don't like the ship Caleo, it's pretty much canon now and there's nothing you can do to change it.

~ Defeating giants without the help of a god

This isn't possible.

It's stated that giants can't be killed without the help of a god and/or goddess.

Alyconeus was an exception because he was only immortal in Alaska, but that's it.

And like don't re-use that same tactic of only being immortal in a certain territory because that's really cliche, and it's already been done

~ OC survived Tartarus

I've probably already made this point but rEALLY

The only demigods to have ever survived Tartarus were Nico, Annabeth, and Percy.

Nico's a pretty strong demigod and probably went through on his own with pure luck and the nature that he has.

Percy and Annabeth had each other, and also Bob, and had Damasen's help for the last bit that they were in Tartarus

So, I'm doubting the OC would be able to survive it

~ Characters making friends with Titans and giants

nonononono

The only reason Bob was Percy and Annabeth's friend was because his memory was wiped and Nico convinced the giant that Percy was a good guy

Damasen was just a pretty lonely dood who was sent to Tartarus because he helped demigods

There are not many Titans and giants that, if at all, will befriend demigods

just no

~ Percy's sass level is way too high

He's not even that sassy in the books

Yeah, he can be a bit of a smart aleck sometimes, but he's not always sassy

~ Blackjack, Tempest, Arion

Where dey @

~ Frazel

Honestly I don't think Frazel gets enough love in a lot of fanfics.

I'm not saying this for every fanfiction, but you get my point

~ No sign of confident OCs

A lot of OCs are just really Mary Sue and are always really insecure about themselves

Again, not saying this for every OC because in actuality I've seen my share of really good and realistic OCs

~ OC has to fall in love with someone

The word doesn't revolve around love??? I mean it's okay to have your main character fall in love with someone, but I haven't seen many fanfiction where it hasn't happened

••••

I'm thinking of writing an actual PJO/HoO fanfic.

should it be a crossover or just regular? And if crossover, which kind of crossover??