Domesticated (Ticci Toby x Neko! Reader)

ლ Six ლ

"No, as hard as it is to believe, cocky and conceited isn't exactly my type." you joked. Toby took this as a sign of relief and he sighed.

"Okay, good."

---------------------------

You wake up and spring out of bed. "CHRISTMAS!" you shout childishly, evidently waking up Toby and Ironic who's rooms were on either sides of yours. You slide down the railing and downstairs to see the creepily decorated Christmas tree. No, not organs or muscle tissue. Just spooky, unsettling and disturbing ornaments. You guys couldn't use human entrails because then E.J. would start complaining about wasting food.

Several presents decorate the bottom of the tree, causing you to smile in delight. Ironic and Toby walk down rubbing there eyes. "That's quite a scream you got there." Ironic says sleepily. You grin and stand on your tip toes, placing a black Santa hat on Ironic and an orange and gray one on Toby. The brunette blushes softly and turns his gaze towards the staircase as the other creepypastas file in. You pull more Santa hats out and place them on the corresponding members. They all giggle at your enthusiasm and crowd around the Christmas tree. The first gift goes to BEN. It's a new controller with a green base and black paint dripping down it. He squeals and jumps up and down, clutching it to his chest.

You all burst out laughing and next E.J. opens his gift from you. It's a jar packed full of kidneys. He takes off his mask and glomps you, tackling you to the ground. He rubs his cheek against yours. "Thanks~!" You chuckle and pat his back, jealousy radiating from Ironic and Toby.

The next person to open their gift is Smiley. It's a new, high grade scalpel. He twirls the medical razor around his fingers and his mask rides up to show that he's smiling. "Thanks, kiddo." he says, glancing over at Masky and ruffling his hair. Masky and Hoodie's gifts are next, and evidently they gifted each other. Masky gets cheesecake scented cologne and Hoodie gets a shirt with a cheesecake picture on it. They hug each other happily. The pasta to come next is none other than Jeff himself. He rips open his box with his trusty knife and frowns when he sees his gift.

It's a book titled: "How the Jeff stole Christmas." it has a dorky picture on the cover and you all laugh, having pitched in to the creation of the awesome masterpiece. He reads it out loud, his face turning red with anger the whole time. By the end of the story all the pastas are bent over laughing hysterically. Jeff chucks a present at Toby. He opens it to see about four packs of waffle mix. He blinks a couple times and laughs. 

"Thanks Jeff!" Toby chirps. Surprisingly, the only person to get two gifts was you. They were from Toby and Ironic.

Toby's gift was catnip. Your raise an eyebrow. "Really?" He laughs.

"Look u-nder neath the tis-sue paper." he explains.

You rip it off to see an old fashioned shotgun with your name carved into the side. "Awwe, thanks Tobes!" you say, hugging the brunette male. He flushes and hugs you back.

"Alright, here (First Name)!" Ironic says, handing you his present. You hold it up to the light and shake it next to your ear. You stick your tongue out the corner of your mouth and tear it open with your claws. A jack-in-the-box pops up causing you to scream and cling onto Ironic. He chuckles at your reaction. "Your real present is inside." he says through laughs.

"Gee, thanks." you say, letting go of him and crawling back over to the box. You pluck the puppet out and chuck it elsewhere int he room, scavenging for the real present. Once you find it you smile. It's a (Favorite Color) beanie with holes cut out for your ears to stick through. 

"Try it on!" Ironic ushers. You tug it on and smile as your ears and tail flick happily. They all make an 'Awwe' sound and you blush slightly, looking down. Needless to say, it was an amazing Christmas.

x Time Skip x

You sit in Toby's room with him watching 'How the Grinch stole Christmas'. You laugh at all the corny parts and the brunette leans his head on your shoulder. You blush and discreetly cuddle closer to him, enjoying his warmth. Toby's arms snake around your waist and his head goes from your shoulder to rest on the top of your head. After a moment, you two fall asleep like that. It's completely unnoticed to you that Toby had hung a sprig of mistletoe right above his door frame, too.

------------------------------------------------

Merry Christmas!!!!