Okay I should probably stop putting all my rants here, but it just really annoys me when I say "I don't like Bluestar" and everyone's like "OMG HOW COULD YOU SAY THAT??"
So everyone's like "Bluestar is my favorite character because she's been through so much and still became a great leader!"
1. Look at Crookedstar. 2. No, she wasn't a great leader. ThunderClan's size was pretty much cut in half by the time Into The Wild started. Now, I know that wasn't really her fault but she could have avoided deaths by not sending her warriors into battle for stupid Sunningrocks.
So, I get why some of you like her. She's been through a lot and managed to pull through it to become leader. (Even though she did kinda murder her own kit because of her ambition...)
But remember Crookedstar? His entire family was killed and he was manipulated against his own Clan, but he realized what was right and earned his leader name. And Crookedstar was actually a decent leader.
Towards the end of her days, Bluestar literally didn't trust her own Clan. And look at what she did to Brightheart! She was a cold and cruel cat for at least half of her leadership and the entire fandom is in love with her because her mom and sister died.
