Casey Jones X Reader (2012 Version)

When You Meet The Turtles

Casey had just finished telling you about the turtles and that you could meet them. "So you have mutant friends? Why am I not surprised that you of all people would have mutants for friends." You said putting a hand on your hip. "So you're not freaked out?" Casey asked nervously. "Totally not! I think being friends with mutants would be cool! I'd love to meet them!" You said. Casey smiled happily. You got a dreamy look on your face, you loved his handsome smile. You quickly wipe away the expression before Casey can notice. Casey grabbed your hand and dragged you along. He finally stopped in front of a manhole cover. "Um why are we at a manhole cover Casey?" You ask sending him a confused glance. "This is where they live, in the sewers!" Casey said as he started to lift up the manhole cover. "Doesn't it smell bad though?" You ask looking down the dark tunnel. "You'll get used to it." Casey said as he climbed down the ladder. You let out a disgusted groan as you followed him down. Casey took you through a bunch of different tunnels before he stopped at an entrance. "Here we are, I'll take you inside now." Casey said as the two of you walked in. As you step in your mouth falls open. For a sewer the place looked really nice. There was a couch and even a tv. There were even other rooms including a fully stocked kitchen. Suddenly six figures walk out into the room. "Guys this is (Y/N)!" Casey cheers gesturing to you. "Hi!" You say shyly giving a little wave. You look at the six figures, four are humanoid turtles and one is a giant humanoid rat. Then you see the last person is someone you recognize, April O'Neil. "April what are you doing here?!" You nearly yell. "The turtles are my friends too!" April says slightly annoyed. "Well you already know April but why don't the of the guys introduce themselves!" Casey said. Then one of the turtles in an orange mask runs up to you. "I'm Michelangelo but you can call me Mikey!" Mikey says as he shakes your hand. Then the turtle in the blue mask speaks up. "I am Leonardo but my friends call me Leo." Leo says in a calm tone. Then the turtle in the red mask starts to talk. "The name's Raphael but call me Raph." Raph says nodding at you. Finally the last turtle wearing a purple mask speaks. "Hi I'm Donatello but everyone calls me Donnie." Donnie says giving you a warm smile. Then you hear the rat start to talk. "And I am Splinter. I welcome you into our home and family." Splinter says looking over you. "It's a pleasure to meet all of you." You say happily. You see April roll her eyes out of the corner of your eye. You want to confront her about it but you want to make a good impression with the others. Mikey then drags you and Casey over to the couch and puts some old cartoon on the tv. You laugh and smile as you watch the show. You don't notice Casey staring at you with a loving smile and a blush covering his cheeks. He loved your laugh. You all spend the rest of the day getting to know each other and having fun.