Jeff's P.O.V:
I was walking back to the mansion with (Y/N) we both finished killing our last victims for the night. I really liked her we both had things in common we both killed our families, went insane and liked killing people in there sleep. When we got to the mansion (Y/N) looked at me "Hey Jeff I'm gonna go take a shower you wanna hang out after I'm done?" She asked
I shrugged "Sure why not" I said "Ok" she said then left. "Really Jeff sure why not the F**k is wrong with you" I said in my head and facepalm then EJ walked in "Hey A**hole" he said "F**k off" I said then flipped him off "So when are you going to tell her" he said
"What! How did you know that I was going to tell (Y/N)" I said "Ben and Toby told me" EJ said "Is this what I get for being an a**hole" I said "Probably" he said I glared at EJ "Anyways how are you going to tell her" he asked
"I don't know I'll just tell her how I feel and hope she won't reject me" I said "Don't worry Jeff if (Y/N) rejects you I'll be here for you and we could drink our problems away" he said I hit the back of his head "Idiot" I said
Your P.O.V
After I was took a shower and got dressed when I was going back downstairs I saw Ben "Hey (Y/N)" he said "Hi Ben" I responded "so when are you going to tell Jeff" he said smirking I blushed "h-how did y-you know I-I liked h-him" I stuttered "Toby told me" he said.
"Wow thanks Toby" I said in my head "please don't tell Jeff" I begged "I won't" he said "thank you" I said in relief "but I think you should confess to him" Ben said "But if I tell Jeff he might not like me back and might not want to be my friend anymore" I said
"Hey at least you tried and if he doesn't want to be your friend anymore he can go F**k himself" he said I smiled and playfully punched his arm "thanks" I said he smiled back "No problem" he said
"I'm gonna confess to him I'll probably see you later" I said "ok that's if you don't have a makeout session with him" he said I lightly blushed "yeah ok" I said rolling my eyes he laughed "bye Ben" I said "bye (Y/N)" he said I then went downstairs
Jeff's P.O.V:
I saw (Y/N) coming downstairs "I'm back" she said "so you want to watch a movie" I asked "sure" she said I walked to the living room and sat on the couch and (Y/N) sat by me I put on her favorite horror movie (Favorite horror movie you like) and turned on the TV.
"Oh cool I love this horror movie" (Y/N) said I chuckled "I can see that" I said "how did you know this was my favorite horror movie" she asked I shrugged "Just guessed" I said she giggled and looked back at the TV.
I lightly blushed "come on Jeff just tell her how you feel it's not hard" I said in my head I took a deep breath "Hey (Y/N)" I said "yeah Jeff" she said "I need to tell you something" I said "what's up?" She asked
"I wanted to tell you that I really like you and I wanted to know if you would be my girlfriend" I said and turned away she tapped my shoulder I looked back at her and she kissed me I looked at her shocked but then kissed back.
She pulled away "I love you Jeff" (Y/N) said "I love you more (Y/N)" I said and kissed her she kissed back then we went too far and had a makeout session but I didn't care until Ben came in and took a picture of us "Ben" (Y/N) and I both said while blushing.
"There I sent it to EJ" he said "Now EJ has to pay me" Ben said smiling "Hey Ben" (Y/N) said "Yeah" Ben said "If you want we could pay you with a foot up your a** if you don't delete that" she said Ben then ran away quickly (Y/N) looked at me "You wanna chase him" she said I smirked "H*ll yeah" I said then we both chased Ben around the mansion
(I hope you guys like it I tried and please comment and I'll try to do your X reader or ship for you guys and I also want to thank you all for reading ExoticSushiManiac Creepypasta Headcanons she made it to 400 views because of you guys and I'm really happy for her if you haven't read her Headcanons you should and please go check out my other friends books there amazing)
WeLoveThenHate
RoamingOtaku
grell101
Actual_Sushi_Roll
LaRainHernandez
MadisonCianciarulo
MarredViridity
-MsCreepyPasta-( Please go check out there stories and have a nice day)