Creepypasta X Reader One Shots

Surrender x Caring! Reader

Ever since Slendy needed more Creepypastas, you had to watch the kids. You often played with them since you were used to be around kids, your aunt owned a day care that you'd work over the summer. "GAH! Oh noos! Alex, you killed me!" You said dramatically as you fell onto your back. Alex was a boy who used plastic knives as weapons. He acted kinda like Jeff. "NUUU! MISS (Y/N)! I'M SOWORRY!" Alex cried as the other kids gathered around you, you opened your left eye as Surrender walked by. "Pffft... You guys can't even tell it was ketchup!" You laughed as you sat up.

Alex looked up with tears in his eyes as you showed the cheap ketchup bottle Alex had apparently stabbed. "I... I knew it was ketchup the entire time!" Alex said as a little girl with demon horns looked at him weird. "Then why were you crying that you 'killed' Miss (y/n)?" "SHUT UP LIA!" Surrender smiled softly as you ruffled Alex's hair. He's had a crush on you ever since you've met him. You seemed so nice and caring to him. "Hi Mr. Stevie!" Surrender looked down to see Annie, a girl who was kinda like BEN_Drowned. "Oh. Hi Annie. What do you need?"

"I just wanna know why you keep looking at Miss (y/n)." Surrender blushed and started to get nervous. "AAH! ANNIE! GET SPIKE OFF ME!" Abby, a girl who was to much like Masky, winced as a small lizard climbed onto her shirt. "Coming you big cry baby..." Annie groaned, Surrender sighed in relief before his older brother Slender walked over. "Ok little ones, time for training." You got each of the four kids ready, you were crying with joy as the four followed Slender. "My little babies are off to murder people... I'm so proud!"

Surrender walked over with flowers behind his back as you laughed at what you just said. "Hey... (y/n)?" You looked at Surrender, noticing he was blushing like crazy. "Y..You... I mean... I.. um..." Surrender just shoved the flowers into your arms, making you blush a little. Surrender had his head down a little as you examined the flowers, they were (fav/color) (fav/flower). "Aww! Thank you Stevie!" Surrender looked up before you kissed his cheek and left to put the flowers in a vase. Surrender was blushing as he watched you leave.

'She's so sweet'