Creepypasta X Reader One Shots

Imagine...

Proxies finding out you're pregnant. (They're not father, you were raped from some sicko at bar.)

Toby:
*You both were great friends at first

*When you tell him about this over the phone, he comes over immediately

*Details. What does he look like? What car does he drive? Where does he live? SO HE CAN KILL HIM, GOD DAMN IT!!!

*Accepts father-role tHE SECOND YOU MENTION IT

*Actually helps hide you from Slender until you feel like he needs to know

*Holds baby up just like Simba in the Lion King as Masky is yelling at him to put your (son/daughter) down

*Skipping to 5 years, he asks you to marry him

Hoody:
*He comes to you since you haven't been over to contacting them for nearly 4 weeks

*Sees you throwing up because of morning sickness

*Holds you as you tell him everything

*"Do you know where he lives? I wanna chat with him. With my GUN."

*Accepts father-role when you ask him too

*Tells you that he will explain to Slender and PROMISES it will be ok

*Lets the baby be wrapped up in his favorite hoodie

*"Hey. We should get married now."

Masky:
*Honestly. He always had a hutch.

*You're throwing up EVERY morning and you're eating that one ice cream nobody likes. NOBODY.

*He asks you in private just to be holding you in his arms

*"Ok. Give me his address so I can cut off his d🍆ck."

*Um. He accepted the father-role the second he found out.

*Hides it from Slender at first, but, when Slender asked, he answered.

*Lets the baby hold his finger and has his mask lifted up so he can see the baby clearly.

*With the help* of 6 year old (son/daughter name), he proposed to you

EJ:
*He smelled it.

*He's holding your hair, keeping your diet on track, he is best husbando

*Since he can smell the man on you... eh... he got kidneys that night

*Told Slender but also warmed Slender about hurting you

*Purrs against you as you're holding your (son/daughter)

*Skip to 4 years, EJ asks you to marry him woth your child holdomg a sign saying "say yes"

*pressure