{Editing} Creepypasta Boyfriend / Girlfriend Scenario & Head Cannons

They fall for you (Edited)

( A/N So i think it would be easier if there was a gender to do this so i'm just going with a girl, sorry if your a guy or a they.
Future me: Nah we doing all gender now.)

[Their point of view]

Jeff the Killer
I hate to say it, but I think I have a thing for (Y/N). They make me feel... weird. I can't explain it but I feel something, I've never felt before. I think I like them... I want them for my own.

Ben Drowned
Why, Why them? First my target, then a friend and now I like them! Why didn't I kill them? It would of been so easy. Why are they stuck in my head even when I'm not with them! And why can't they be mine?

Eyeless Jack
They're so smart, so nice and I could of killed that amazing person. I'm glad I didn't because if I did, I probably wouldn't be so happy after I hunt. I just hope they could love a monster like me.

Laughing Jack
Oh my dear (Y/N), I don't know how but you stole my heart. The thought of you makes me crazier. I want you to be my (Y/N) in a box.... I've made you a box.

Jane the killer
Being with them is like being normal again. Free from everything, not a care in the world... Besides them. They're so bright and beautiful I can't help but love them. I want them to be a part of the rest of my life. I just hope it doesn't end like it did in the past...

Masky
It's funny both me and Hoodie met the person we like on the same day. Because we trust each other, we talk about them all the time. (Y/N) is the best thing that happened to me ever since I join Slenderman. I'd do anything to keep them with me.

Hoodie
Masky is the one person I've told about my crush on (Y/N). He has one too, Maybe if we ask them out we can go on a double date!... I'd like to at least, if (Y/N) feels the same.

Dr. Smiley
(L/N).... I fear they're scared of me, I won't blame them. I started out as a kind and caring doctor, and now they probably sees me as a monster. Yet, they never throw up or looks away. They just listen and watch without a word. I feel so different with them.

Bloody Painter
At first they were a bit odd, but they've grown on me. The way they draw I find beautiful. In all honesty I've began to fall for them, (Y/N) is a masterpiece and I would love for them to be mine.

Smile Dog
They're one of the coolest people I've ever met. We like around the same things and they lets me be myself, dog and all. Over time I think I'm starting to like them, but I don't think they would date someone like me.

Ticci Toby
(Y/N) I-Is ama-zing *tic*! T-hey never m-make fun of m-me and *tic* l-likes the t-things I do. W-when i'm with them I-I feel *tic* something, a-after a long t-time of n-nothing, I feel something *tic*.

Lost sliver
(Y/N) is one of my best friends now. The more I hang out with them the more I know I like them. They're so fun to be around and they never push me to do things. I want to ask them out so badly be I'm just to shy.

(A/N) Sorry i took so little long