{Editing} Creepypasta Boyfriend / Girlfriend Scenario & Head Cannons

They ask you out/ They become your Lover (Edited)

( Thanks for the votes and follows. It lets me know you're liking it and it makes me happy to see it!!!!)

Jeff the Killer
You were sitting in you're home waiting for Jeff, he was taking forever to get there. He promised he'd be there soon, but it looked like he wasn't coming today. You waited so long, you ended falling asleep, only to wake up later to a knock at the door. You look at the clock.
[1:32 AM]

'Who in the world is knocking at this time?' You thought, opening the door to see Jeff with a hand behind his back. 'That sounds about right.' You then spoke to him,
"Look who finally decided to show up." You crossed your arms as he looked off somewhere else.
"Look, I'm sorry I'm late or whatever... I was thinking..." He finally made eye contact as he finished speaking.

"What about exactly?" You questioned, hands now on your hips. He took his hand out from behind his back, in it was a single rose, cut mostly likely with his knife. Confusion filled your head as you stared at the little flower.
"Look, I'm not good at this type of thing, but flowers were important I was told so, um... I like you? God this dumb, ok, I wanted to be your boyfriend. So just... Will you go out with me?"
"Of course, Jeff." You laughed slightly at his attempt of being 'romantic.' Hugging him tightly, you took the rose from him and put it in a vase. For the rest of the night, you planned for a date tomorrow.

Ben Drowned
You were playing an online shooter
(A/N your pick) when things started getting weird. Other players would twitch and glitch all over the place. Plus everyone mic's keep cutting out.

It got to the point where you were about to quit all together, but the game ended in the middle of it, your team had won. You were confused, you were losing and then you won, how did that happen? Looking the screen over, a box not from the game popped up saying, [ Be my player two? Yes or No ~Love BEN]

You couldn't believe it at first. Your face burned as a large smile grew on your expression. Without a word you clicked yes. It only took a few seconds before Ben jump out of the screen and hugged matching your smile.

Eyeless Jack
You and E.J were walking in the park one late night so no one was around. The walk was very calming, but tiering. While walking you saw a tree with a swing for two, so you pulled Jack over to take a break. Your break because a hour long talk under the stars.

After a small joke, E.J paused all together and set back on the swing.
"Is something wrong?" You asked. "Well there's something I want to tell you, but I think you will hate me if I told you." He faced you the best he could, taking his mask off.
"Jack you're my friend, you can tell me."

He sighed when you said the word friend.
"That's the thing... Being friends is amazing, but I want to be more than that... I like you." He had a sad smile on his face as he turned his head downwards. Your cheeks grew red as you smiled.
"I like you too, Jack." You said, taking his hand in yours. He hold your hand back as the two of you continued your talk.

Laughing Jack
"L.J!" You called, hearing the front door open. Jack would come in whenever he wanted nowadays, so you'd call to make sure it's him.
"YES (Y/N)?!" He yelled back.
"JUST CHECKING!" You laughed, walking down stairs.

Once you made it to the living room, you noticed him holding a clear bag with different colored candies in it.
"What do you got there?" You questioned, walking up to the clown.
"Well Dear (Y/N), I've made this candy." He said, a proud smile on his face.

"Wow, can I try some?" You asked, knowing he wouldn't poison it.
"Of course" He smiled slightly, a different atmosphere coming off of him, as he held out the bag.
You picked a (F/C = Favorite color) candy and opened it. You took the candy out and looked at the rapper it said,
[ Will you be my laughing (Y/N)?]