Ticci Toby x reader

chapter 5

You and Jane were watching the whole thing, laughing your arses off and choking on air, tears pricking both your eyes.

Jeff finally stopped, almost out of breath, and as the green eyed girl withdrew her hand to bring Charlie down onto Jeff's head when said male took out his large carving knife. "I think Miss Sally wants Charlie to have another surgery..."

Sally squeaked and ran back to the bed, hiding behind Jane. "You buttface!" She shouted, peeking out from behind said killer. "Leave Charlie out of this!"

The black haired male glared at Jane and Sally menacingly. "Then get OUT. Now." He paused and smiled wider, if that was even possible. "Or go to sleep."

You shivered involuntarily as the two girls slowly made their way out of your room, shooting you apologetic looks.

"You better not lay a finger on her." Jane hissed as she passed her rival. "Or else you'll wake up with a knife in your throat."

Jeff rolled his eyes... or tried to.

"Good luck with big bro, N/N!" Sally called before turned around the corner. "And make sure to name one of your babies after me!"

You could hear Jane's muffled giggle as they slowly walked out of earshot, and you could very  much hear Jeff's snickers from beside you. "Sally Rogers." He said, drawling out the last name. "Has a nice ring to it."

The killer turned to face you only to come eye-to-nozzle as you sprayed him directly in the eyes with salt water.

Yep. You were that awesome.

"ARGHHH! HOLY- WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?!" Jeff shrieked, blindly trying to rub the concoction of death out of his eyes, or what it looked like to you, scratch out his eyes.
And he wasn't succeeding either way.

"Ok, what do you want Jeff?" You snapped, throwing a piece of tissue at him, to which he flailed to grab and began to furiously scrub at his eyeballs. "My CoD Ghosts? The extra Xbox controller? My knife sharpener cause you broke the other one over BEN's head? Your other stash of knives cause Slends hid them?" You crossed your arms and huffed.

Jeff held up his hands in surrender. "No, I don't need any of those." He paused. "Ok, maybe the last two."

You glared at him.

"Ok, ok!" He took in a deep breath, making you tap your foot impatiently.

"Well?" Your hand made its way back to the spray bottle, making Jeff yelp.

"I was getting to it, calm down!" He shouted, smacking your hand away. "Toby didn't stand you up the other night."

You raised an eyebrow. "Oh really?"

"Yes, really. He was out killing just before your little date, saying he was 'warming up' or something stupid like that. Then the police finally caught up to him."

"I highly doubt that the police were able to restrict a boy who can't feel pain and can throw a hatchet like a professional marksman."

"Will you let me finish?!" Jeff snapped and you automatically shut your mouth, but not before huffing indignantly. "Alright, so the police caught up with him, but your boyfriend ended up spazzing out and killing all of the officers who showed up as well as everyone on the street." He paused again. "However, when Slender came back with him, and he was unconscious, I heard him talking to EJ, and he said that when Toby broke into one of the houses, he killed the parents, but when he got to the daughter, he couldn't bring himself to lop her head off."

"So he threw it at her back?"

"No." Jeff glared at you, to which you merely shrugged. "Because she looked like you."

"Ooook... so I have a doppelganger?"

"NO. I swear, you're so stupid sometimes." The black haired male complained, to which you smacked him upside the head. "He cares about you. You know how much he loves killing and getting his hands bloody, plus he killed a whole street's worth of people. But he spared one girl because she looked like you." He paused. "But seeing that he sorta went crazy at the time, his brain was probably playing tricks on him so that girl probably didn't look exactly like you, but that proves he was thinking of you."

"Ok, fine. That's really sweet, I think, but it still doesn't explain why he stood me up." You crossed your arms.

"I'm not finished." The male interrupted, glaring at you. "They caught up to him. Before Slender did."

You raised an eyebrow questioningly. "They?"

Jeff looked from side to side, as if someone was watching you two (which there most likely was). "Yes, they."

You groaned in frustration. "Ok Jeff if you're not gonna tell me who 'they' is, I'll just spray you in the face and go make my blood waffles."

"NO!" The two heard a shout and they turned towards the door. "NO! NO MORE BLOODY WAFFLES!"

You were suddenly tackled to the ground by a white and brown blur.

"What the hell?!" You shouted, trying to break free from the person's grip, who was now on top of you and shaking you violently.

Looking up, you took in orange goggles, a blue hood, and a striped sweater.

Your (E/C) eye twitched. "TOBYYYYYY!"

"And that's my cue to leave." Jeff snickered and make his way out of the room.

"Wait! Jeff! You still have to tell me-"

SLAM

"He fixed the door?!"