Jr Year! | A glee fan fiction.

Eight

I walked into the choir room and saw Finn and Sam arguing. Puck was standing next to them and yelling, "Fight! Fight! Fight!" "What the hell is going on?" I asked. "He's a cheater! I know it!" Finn yelled angrily. "No I'm not, Spencer I would never do that to you!" Sam looked at me. I bit my lip, "I don't know who to believe." I looked over at Santana and she shrugged. "Why wouldn't you do the same thing I did to you?" Finn asked. "Calm down Finn. Nothing's going on!" Quinn exclaimed. "You've cheated on me before, how can I believe you?" I heard Finn's voice crack which means he was about to cry. "Please stop, guys." I walked over to them. "No, he cheated on you. I'm gonna kill him!" Finn looked at me. "You don't mean that." I said calmly. "How are you so calm about this?" Finn asked. "I already told you, it's happened before! Just stop, both of you!" I yelled and quickly walked out.

I looked in the bathroom mirror to see my tear-stained face. The door swung open and Santana walked in. I ran over and hugged her. Then I began crying into her shoulder. She rubbed my back, "Quinn's a b*tch but I don't think she cheated. This time." I pulled away and wiped my tears, "I tried to stay optimistic but I can't. The last two boyfriends I had cheated on me... And Sam was my first kiss." "Your FIRST KISS?" Santana asked. I nodded slowly, "I don't trust people easily. But with Sam, I felt an automatic connection." "Then hear him out." Santana suggested. I nodded and quickly walked back to the choir room, Santana close behind me.

I walked in right as Finn punched Sam in the face. "Stop it!" I grabbed Sam's arm before he could fight back. Puck pulled Finn away. "What is going on?" Mr. Schue walked in. "I'm trying to kill Sam!" Finn struggled as Puck and Mike both held him back. "I didn't cheat!" Sam yelled. I looked at him and he looked back at me. "I promise I didn't cheat on you." Sadness filled his eyes. My head began spinning with thoughts. "I'm sorry Sam... I-I don't want to deal with another broken heart." I turned and walked back out of the choir room and to Ms. Pillsbury's office.

"I need advice." I slumped down into one of the chairs. Ms. Pillsbury looked at me concerningly, "What's wrong?" I let out a deep breathe, "I think Sam cheated on me. But he says he didn't and I don't know what to believe!" She handed me a pamphlet. "I'm sorry, but I need real advice from you. I don't understand pamphlets." I pushed the paper away. "Ok," Ms. Pillsburry folded her hands and placed them on her desk, "Do you trust Sam?" I nodded slowly, "I did." "Do you truly believe that he cheated?" She asked. "I mean, I did. Then I thought about it more, and I don't think so." I explained. "Hear what he has to say." Ms. pillsbury suggested. "You and Santana give good advice." I said. "Santana?" She asked. "I know, surprising." I laughed and walked out.

I sat on the bleachers watching football practice. Finn got back on the team and Artie joined, so that was my excuse as to why I'm here. But I'm really just here to talk to Sam. The practice ended and everyone went into the lockeroom. A few minutes later Finn walked out, "Ride?" "No, I'm gonna talk to Sam." I said. "Be careful. And if it's true you better tell me. Quinn is my girlfriend." Finn said. "I will." I nodded and Finn walked off. About a minute later Sam walked out, he immediately ran over to me. "I didn't cheat!" He exclaimed. "Then what's going on?" I asked sitting down in the bleachers. Sam sat next to me, "First of all, I was drunk. I don't even remember staring at her. And before you say anything, just listen." He stood up and began to sing.

"Saw you on a subway in New York City
Called across the platform but no, you didn't hear me
You took my heart but never left my brain
You're headed up to Harlem on a uptown train

Before that night everything was black and white

And I wanna tell you right now
You're the kinda girl Ray was singing about
I know it sounds crazy, don't know how in this world
But I found my midnight girl

You're friends all wondering what I'm doing round here
I know they're probably wishing that I just disappear
And I know I hear them laughing when I'm out of the room
You can tell them I ain't leaving anytime soon

'Cause you know this life isn't so black and white

And I wanna tell you right now
You're the kinda girl Ray was singing about
I know it sounds crazy, don't know how in this world
But I found my midnight girl

They all say we're from two different worlds
I'ma say we're a boy and a girl
Call me crazy but it's all the same to me

And I wanna tell you right now
You're the kinda girl Ray was singing about
I know it sounds crazy, don't know how in this world
But I found my midnight girl"

I smiled, "I believe you." "Good, because you mean everything to me." Sam grabbed my hand and pulled me into a kiss. I kissed him back then pulled away, "I love you and all, but I need a ride home." Sam laughed and we held hands as we went to the parking lot.