Nerd or Rockstar? (Black Veil Brides/Criminal Minds Fanfiction)

Spencer... Or Andy...?

Georgia's POV

Spencer was still with me when we received the information that the brothers had been unwantingly 'taken care of'.

Andy and Juliet had joined us about an hour after that.

"What're you guys doing here?" I asked, sipping at the cup of water I had been given with my lunch.

"We came to check on Sammi and thought we'd come see how you're doing whilst we're here." Juliet smiled, weakly.

I nodded and smiled back in the same way, unable to make eye contact with her after what went down between Andy and I a few days ago.

"Thank you. How is she?" I asked.

"She's fine. Broken leg, concussion and slightly starved, but she's doing ok." Andy replied.

I nodded again.

Spencer took my hand and gave me a reassuring smile, making me smile back.

"How're you holding up?" Andy asked.

"I'm fine. In some pain but the medication here is incredible." I chuckled, causing a shot of pain to go through my side.

I grabbed it and winced.

"Stop making her do that! It's obviously hurting her." Juliet raised her voice a little, slapping Andy's forearm.

"Sorry..." Andy mumbled, shuffling uncomfortably.

I smiled through my pain at him in reassurance.

"It's alright. Not your fault. I was just doing my job." I told him.

"You did more than that. You took a bullet for Sammi. You deserve a damn good reward or something." Andy chuckled.

"You saved her Georgia. You. I'd say that was the perfect result to a first case." Spencer smiled at me, which I returned.

But the true feelings i was feeling included confusion and frustration.

The last two sentences that had been spoken in that room were from the two people i cared about deeply.

And they were both trying to make me feel better.

Truth was... I just melted.

I was half gone as soon as Andy stopped speaking. But Spencer finished me off.

"Ugh!!!" I sighed, loudly, flailing my arms in the air.

"What?" Andy asked with a very confused expression on his face.

I sighed again and looked away.

I didn't know what to do!

"Are you in pain or something?" Juliet questioned, sympathetically.

I shook my head.

Truth was, i was in emotional pain. I had no idea what to do about my feelings towards my nerd and the rockstar.

I was dating the nerd...

But I felt like - Because of the band - I knew the rockstar better.

The emotions inside me felt like my heart was a cauldren and it's contents slowly being stirred by an evil witch.

"No... Sorry, just frustrated with things..." I mumbled, looking in the direction that meant i didn't have to make eye contact with any of them.

The other members of the room nodded as there was a knock on the door.

Sammi sat in a wheelchair, pushed by Morgan.

They were both smiling at me as they entered the room.

"I hear you're my savior." Sammi smiled.

I smiled and nodded.

"I guess I am."

"Well all I can say is thank you. Thank you so much. I could never day that enough but it's all I have at the moment. I owe you my life Agent Borrowdale." She smiled as a small tear trickled down her soft, porcelain cheek.

"Oh... No Sammi. It's fine. It's what I get paid for. I was just doing my job." I pleaded for her to stop.

I didn't think talking to Sammi about my 'Andy/Spencer' issue was a good idea.

"I'm gunna go get food. Anyone want anything?" Juliet asked after a while a silence.

Andy nodded and hugged her, kissing her cheek, before telling her what he wanted.

Spencer handed her some money and asked her for a turkey sandwich and bag of chips.

"Nothing for me thanks Juliet." I said, giving her a weak smile.

"Can I come along?" Sammi asked, looking at Juliet with mesmerising eyes.

Juliet smiled and nodded, giving Sammi the money so she could hold the handles to the wheelchair correctly.

They left, leaving Andy, Spencer, Morgan and I in the room alone...

I looked over to Morgan and he gave me the 'awkward' eyes.

We both looked between Andy and Spencer before everting our eyes back to one another.

"Guys could I talk to Agent Borrowdale real quick?" He asked the boys, who nodded.

Spencer got up and kissed my head before joining Andy on the chairs outside the ward.

Morgan closed the door and sat in the chair that was previously occupied by Spence.

He sighed heavily.

"So whatcha thinking?" He asked with his head in his hands.

My turn to sigh.

"I have no idea... Those boys will be the death of me." I chuckled humorlessly.

He smiled a toothy smiled and patted my thigh lightly.

"It'll be fine. If they really like you the way I think they do, you'll make up your mind." He told me.

"That's the thing though. I'm the one that can't decide. At the end of the day, I'm the one who has to decide between the two. I'm the one who has to make up my mind about two people I care a hell of a lot about. I'm just not sure I could do this alone. Help me Morgan... Please..." I moped.

"We'll lets go through your options." He smiled, leaning back in his chair.

I thought about it for a moment.

"I feel like I know Andy better." I started. "But he has Juliet."

"The guy's willing to give her up for you! Ok, that's not really the right thing to do. You would at least have to wait little while so it doesn't look like he left Juliet for you." Morgan reasoned.

I nodded.

"But I'd get to see Spencer almost everyday. I'd barely get to see Andy because of work."

"And when you did see Andy, it would be more special because of how little you see him, whereas not so much with Spencer because you see him everyday. Think about it." He linked his fingers together and rested them on his stomach.

"True..." I sighed.