The Challenge of Picking Just One

Chapter 5: Justin's Party Part 2

As the dark figure made his way closer to us I could make out the face. Oh my god it's Justin Bieber!!

"Yeah, that's justin and I'm dan, and that's jack over there." dan said being his smartass self, but right now not even that could miss this up for me. I'm gonna fan girl!

"OH MY GOD it's Justin Bieber! I'm going to meet Justin Drew Bieber! If I fant or forget to talk tell him, my names Aiyana and I love him" I said jumping up and down pulling on Finn's hand and Dans arm.

"tell him yourself, cause here he comes" Dan said pulling his arm for my tight hold.

"hey guys! How's it going?" justin asked stopping in front of us.

"Ready to get my party on!" Jack said walking away to the dance floor. Justin eyes soon locked with mine. Oh my god! Justin's eyes locked with mine!

"So beautiful, would you wanna dance?" Justin asked

"M-me?" I stuttered

"Yeah, you." he said holding his hand out to me. I was going to take it before I realized I was here with Finn. Hell I'm holding hands with the damn boy.

"Do you mind Finny?" I asked sweetly hoping he'd say no.

"Go ahead cutie" he smiled whispering "as long as you come back to me " in my ear letting go.

~Finn's P.O.V~

As Aiyana walked away with Justin disappearing into the crowd of people, my fake smile wiped clean off my face. Why couldn't I have said what I wanted to.. Stay with me... Those were the words I wanted to leave my mouth but instead I said fucking go ahead! What the hell is wrong with me?!

"You literally just let her walk away with Justin Bieber. You know Justin Bieber the one every girl wants in their pants" Dan stated not even cracking a smile. "quick question, what the fuck is wrong with you?" dan yelled turning to face me.

"What you think I actually wanted to let her walk away so she can go grind on Justin fucking Bieber! No! But I'm not gonna be the one to stop her, I might be her date here but I'm not her boyfriend. As her best friend why didn't you stop her?!" I yelled back rising my voice higher to be heard better over the music, or at less that was my reason if he said why I was yelling. But seriously I was getting pissed at Dan, and at myself.

"Because I'm not her date here! You are! But if I was her date I would have...." his voice trailed off as he's face softened.

"You would have what?! You would have done the same damn thing." I said all my anger coming out of me "you would have let her walk away too" I spoke quickly before walking away. I really needed a beer.

~Aiyana's P.O.V~

I was grinding on Justin within 5 or 10 minutes of dancing with him. When I felt an unexpected bulge in his pants while he started getting handy. I suddenly felt uncomfortable. It might be Justin Bieber but that doesn't mean it makes me any less uncomfortable.

"Justin stop" I said moving his hands back up to my lower back again. It was no use Justin was set on having his hands on my butt. "Justin please stop" I said for what felt like the 100th time. In this very moment I knew I made the wrong choice leaving Finn to dance with Justin. Sure Justin was nice but he was just way to handy for my liking. "Oh my god Justin stop I don't want you hands there"

"What's wrong baby? I thought this was your dream"

"Yeah well dreams over time to come back to reality. The reality behind this is either move your hands or I go find Finn again" I said getting fed up with him. It was either move them or lose them.

"Well sorry love but I really don't like either of these options" he said darkly into my ear. I felt shivers go down but back when he said that and not in a good way. Oh god. I'm scared...

~Finn's P.O.V~

I was sitting at the bar when I finally found Aiyana and Justin dancing. She looking uncomfortable and mad. I watched at she pulled Justin hands up multiple times. She started talking, I think she was telling him to stop. I got up from my chair making my way over, beer in hand. I pushed and shoved people to get to them. As I got closer I heard them arguing.

"What's wrong babe? I thought this was your dream" Justin said with a cheeky smile on his face. He better fuck off.

"Yeah well dreams over time to come back to reality. The reality behind this is either move your hands or I go find Finn again" That's it come find me. Come to me princess. I was only a couple steps away from them now. I stood tall behind Justin making sure he didn't make a move or make her feel uncomfortable again.

"Well sorry love but I really don't like either of these options" he said darkly into my her ear. I could tell she was scared by the way she started panting. She started pushing him away but he had a tight hold on her ass and back. He started kissing her neck while she struggled to get out. I couldn't wait any longer I had to do something.

"Help me" Aiyana said loudly over the music. That's it. I took the beer in my hand and smashed in over his head. He fell to the floor passed out.

"Come on princess let's go!" I yelled grabbing her hand. Dan was still be the beer so I grabbed him on our way out. Then Jack and the door with Phil. We quickly made our way to the car.

"What happened back there?" Jack asked sitting in the passenger seat next to Dan who was driving. Me, Aiyana and Phil pilling in the back.

"N-nothing" Aiyana stuttered still shocked at what I had done.

"I knocked Justin's ass out cold" I said pulling Aiyana into me.

"You what?!" Jack, Dan, and Phil said together.

"How did you do that?" Dan asked a smile playing on his face. Dan mostly thinking 'that a boy'.

"He broke a beer bottle over his head" Aiyana said for me I think finally coming out of shock. She looked up at me smiling "thank you" She smiled kissing me. I smiled into the kiss.

"Nice going" Jack said half joking, half not.

The rest of the ride home was silent. Aiyana fell asleep in my arms quietly. She looked so peaceful. When we got home I picked Aiyana up in my arms and carried her to her apartment. Although I didn't care about going in her pocket to get her keys, I didn't feel like doing that since she has already been felt up tonight. So I got Dan to do it instead. I opened to door laying her on the couch. I pulled a blanket over her before I left her apartment locking the door behind me. I walked into my apartment to be greeted by Jack.

"What the hell were you thinking?!" he yelled at me.

"Please can we talk about this in the morning?" I asked walked to my bedroom and shutting the door behind me.

"We are talking about this in the morning thought Finnegan!" He yelled thought the door. I ignored him and stripped down to my boxers. I quickly crawled into bed and fell into a peaceful sleep knowing that I was the one who saved Aiyana tonight.