Title of Work:
Resilient
Sub-genre
Dystopian/Romantic SF
Author Name:
mangoskies_ (a.k.a. Kat B)
Critique notes from Red_Harvey
*The first two chapters consisting of a trailer and notes really shows you can interact with readers. The note chapter especially illustrates your acknowledgment (and wish) for growth as a writer.
*The use of GIFs and asterisk-like actions (such as *fangirl squeals* and *finger guns*) highlights more positive reader/writer interaction.
*nods*
*As for chapter one, I love love how it starts off with a dictionary term. It's a clever way to set the tone.
*However, I was unsure of what you meant by "Please read the author's note". Is it meant to warn the reader that there may be grammar/plot inconsistencies? Maybe you can re-word for clarity, such as "Please read the note chapter before beginning..."
*Using caps and bold for the first three words of the chapter is eye-catching, nice!
*And whoa, the first sentence is kiss-a-riffic, and makes me want to read more!
*Kinda jealous about your present-tense narrative skills, as I've yet to master it.
*In the third paragraph, you mention Nick "trailing kisses", and then in paragraph four, "Nick trails his fingertips". Strive to vary word usage.
*I'm a fan of alliteration, and so this sentence really caught me:
"...slow designs as our lips move together in sloppy sync."
*In paragraph five, I suggest starting a new paragraph after "I smile at him." Whenever a line of dialogue (perhaps paired with a character action) ends, start a new paragraph.
*Explaining the main character's reasoning for the hook-up pulls me into the story further. I'm intrigued by her need for casual sex, and her implied resentment for her father.
*The fact that you imply the sexual actions without having to divulge further works well for this scene.
*In the paragraph starting with "When I leave Nick's house", consider deleting "that" from the last sentence, as it might read better without it:
Current- "I frown when I get a news alert in angry red letters that flash on the screen."
Revised- "I frown when I get a news alert in angry red letters flash[ing] on the screen."
*Your mention of The Republic and "disease" are the perfect hints to keep the reader going.
*On the paragraph starting with "When I get home, I see my mother", consider changing a word in the last sentence to a showy verb that will catch the reader's attention:
"A floral apron is tied [consider switching this word out for 'fashioned'] around her waist."
*Look to cut the fat wherever possible. For example:
Current- "Her eyes are wide and darting around, and her cheeks are flushed with worry. Her skin looks pale and taut."
Revised- "Her eyes are darting around, cheeks flushed, skin pale and taut."
*Often, emotions are implied when you mention a character's actions. Remember to show and not tell, as you do for most of the chapter anyway. For example, consider deleting "in confusion" in the following sentence, as the frown denotes confusion:
"I frown in confusion, but decide not to push it."
*Oh, poor little Amelia! I wanna take care of her, too :-(
*Consider condensing for clarity:
Current: "My eyes drop to her hands, where blood stains her fingernails."
Revised: "My eyes drop her blood-stained fingernails."
*Omg, Amelia...?!
*Hmm, okay, disease, violent death, the mom is blaming herself...incredibly interesting. Very zombie-esque!
From the way you've set up the main character and story-tension in the first chapter, I'm definitely adding Resilient to my reading list!
YOU ARE READING
Critique and Review
RandomFeel like your story needs less of that and more of this, but you're not sure of the exact that or this? That's where we come in! Submit your work, and we'll get started. Most reviews/critiques will be completed by @Red_Harvey and ambassadors