HE FINDS OUT YOU WITH A STUFF ANIMAL
˗ˏˋDean ˎˊ˗
"What is that (Y/N)?" Dean asked, walking into the bedroom and gesturing to the stuffed bear on your lap.
"Oh... uh... it's nothing," you replied, kind of embarrassed. You had been given it by your late grandfather, the small bear had been with you since you were a child and you cherish it every day because it is one of the few things of him.
"Do you still sleep with your bear?" He asked, raising an eyebrow, with a teasing glint in his apple eyes.
"No..." You mumbled under your breath, lowering your gaze.
"I don't care, you know. It's actually kinda cute." Dean smiles as he takes his shirt off, ready for bed.
Your eyes looked up and you smiled. "Really?"
"Yeah... but I do think I make a better buddy, don't you think?"
"Hmm... that's a tough one," you said, scratching your non-existent beard, "I think my bear is much better at cuddling that you, all you do is actually lie on me rather than cuddle me.
Dean looked offended and taking your teddy bear before replacing it with himself.
You began to stroke his hair, "I guess I'm stuck with you, fat ass"
˗ˏˋSam ˎˊ˗
Sam had called earlier, explaining how he wouldn't be home from the hunt until later, so you had to go to sleep on your own. Usually, this wasn't an issue but tonight, some stuff on the news rattled your nerves so you didn't want to be alone. You grabbed your stuffy that you had as a child from the closet and brought it over to the bed, hoping it would bring you some closure. You cuddled up to it and eventually found yourself falling asleep.
A few hours later, you were awoken by the front door opening and closing. The worst case scenario came into your mind so you buried yourself under the covers and clutched the stuffed animal for dear life, instead of being the skilful hunter you were and grabbing a gun.
You heard the footsteps walking around and make their way to your bedroom. You slowed your breathing and just waited. "(Y/N)?" you heard a familiar voice whisper.
You slowly peered over the covers to see that it was Sam. "Thank god!" you exclaimed, getting out of bed to hug him.
"What's this?" he asked, pointing to the stuffy in your arms.
"I was scared," you answered timidly.
He chuckled at your cuteness. "Well, no need, I'm here now. Come on, let's go to bed yeah? I'll protect you." He kissed your head and the two of you headed off to bed.
˗ˏˋCastiel ˎˊ˗
Castiel had some business with the Winchesters that seemed to be longer than usual so you were currently in bed alone with your stuffed bear for company. Eventually you fell asleep with your bear in your arms, waiting for Castiel to return home.
When he got home, he was exhausted so headed straight for the bedroom. When he walked in, the sight made his sigh with adoration.
There you were snuggled up with your teddy and the blankets formed a cocoon around you. He quickly went to the bathroom to change into his night clothes and then joined you in bed.
He gently pried the bear from you, replacing it with himself. You peaked your eyes open to see what was going on. "Go to sleep cookie, I'm here." You lazily nodded your head and drifted off in his arms.
˗ˏˋGabriel ˎˊ˗
You were sitting in your living room waiting for Gabriel to come home. You had made the stupid mistake of watching 'MAMA' alone and were sitting on the couch, too scared to move. You had an old stuffy with you and at any noise, you would clutch it tighter and tighter to your chest.
About an hour later, the front lock clicked and in walked a tired looking Gabe, who had actually been doing his heavily duties for once. "Hey (Y/N), what are you still doing up?" he asked with a yawn.
"I watched a scary movie and now I'm too scared to go anywhere," you replied, embarrassed.
He let out a tired chuckle and came over to you, wrapping an arm around your shoulders. "Well no need to be scared. I'm with ya now. But I'm tired. Are you ready to go to bed?"
You nodded and yawned. He took your hand and led you up to the bedroom, completely forgetting about the stuffed animal.
˗ˏˋBalthazar ˎˊ˗
You had been on a hunt for days while Balthazar was preoccupied with heavenly duties, you spent days without each other's arms wrapped around each other. But this time the length of that had doubled so you weren't used to the lost feeling. When you had arrived back to your house, Bal wasn't expected home until for another two or three days so you had yourself a replacement.
It was an old stuff teddy of a lion, you held it tightly as you slept.
Bal had arrived home in the middle of the night, all he wanted to do was go to sleep and cuddle his girlfriend he had missing. When he arrived he saw you asleep on his side cuddling a cute stuff toy. He smiles tiredly before getting into much comfortable clothes.
He moves you to your side of the bed and pried the stuff animal off your arms and brought you close. He had to remind himself to tease you about the animal the next morning before falling asleep with you in his arms.
˗ˏˋLucifer ˎˊ˗
"It's not funny Lucifer," You pouted.
Lucifer had found your old stuffed animal beside your side of the bed and you had admitted to him that when he's away, the stuffy helps you sleep. By now you were actually getting upset and Lucifer noticed.
"Oh... I'm sorry kitten I didn't mean to upset you," He said, going over to hug you.
"I just get really lonely when you're not here and having it helps me sleep," You explained, "I know it's pathetic but you're very cuddly. A cuddly devil."
"Aww baby, I'm real sorry. I didn't mean to make fun of you. I miss you a lot too. But I'm not going anywhere for a while, so you have no need to worry. Shall we go take a nap now?" You smiled and nodded allowing him to take your hand and lead you to the bedroom.
˗ˏˋCrowley ˎˊ˗
"You have a stuff hellhound?" Crowley questions, as he holds up a dog stuff toy.
You looked offended as you grabbed the toy back into your possession, "Excuse me, but it's a direwolf, you know from Game of Thrones? It's Ghost, you dickhead and he's very cuddly." You snapped at him.
He looked at you, "Honestly woman, I am a much better cuddling than a stuff toy. I am cuddle you back."
"Prove it." You challenged as you switched the light of next to you, you lied down on the bed and was ready to go to sleep.
You weren't expecting that Crowley would actually get in bed with you and wrap his arm around you whilst bringing you close. You smiled in the dark as you felt your boyfriend relax, you let go of the stuff toy and turn around to wrap your arms around your boyfriend.
YOU ARE READING
SUPERNATURAL ↳ PREFERENCES 2
Fanfiction"I'm trying to conduct a professional negotiation here and you want to talk about dangly bits?" • I don't know at this point!
