Choosing love. Jack Avery(completed)

1: Meeting Why Dont We

It was the morning of September 4, 2017 I had just spent my first night at my new apartment at 1600 Vine in LA. I moved here from Texas and to get a change of scenery and be close to my best friend Logan Paul.
At 11:30am there was a knock at my door. Who else would it be? Only Logan. He was the only person in LA that I knew.

"Just a second!" I yelled.
I quickly threw on a bra and a black tank top and ripped jeans then ran to the door.

"LOGEY!!!!"

"CASEY!!!"

"Oh my goodness man how are you? I've missed you so much!"

"Same Case same. I'm good. I have a surprise for you."

"Oh?"

"I know you love Why Don't We and I just so happen to know them. Wanna meet them today? Like right now?"

"What the f***?! Yes Logan!!"

"Ok go put on a cuter top then!"

That was Logan's way of saying I'm not going anywhere with you until you put on Maverick merch. I changed my shirt into my "Logang" tank top. Then we hopped in Logans Mercedes G-Wagon called "The Yeti" we took the 20 minute drive to the Why Don't We house. Logan runs in and hold up his fingers like a gun and starts "shooting" the boys.

I'm freaking out I'm in the Why Don't We house right now just standing here. Oh my goodness!

"Thass muhh boiiis" Logan says to the boys and they all fist bump each other. Then I spot them....

Jonah and Jack the two guys I have a crush on in Why Don't We. My two favorites.

"Guys this is Casey one my best friends. She just moved here from Texas near where your from Zach. Casey this is Zach, Corbyn, Jonah, Jack, and Daniel.

"Nice to meet you Casey" All the boys said

"You have no idea guys." I said

"Ah I guess she's a fan." Zach said

"Yupp. Big times she has 2 favorites let's take a guess at who?" Logan said

"Just by the way she's looking I'm gonna say....Hmmmm....Jonah and Jack." Zach said

"Yupp Zach your right." I said.

"So where near me are you from?" Zach said

"Oh Burleson." I said

"Oh cool! I love Burleson. It's so pretty."

We just hung out for a while I kept staring at Jonah and Jack knowing full and well that I'd never have a chance with either one of them but damn they sure are hot!

"So Casey who is cuter me or Jonah." Jack said

"Oooh that's a tough one." I said. "I don't know if I can chose"

*****TIME SKIP****

At 6pm I ask Logan if we can either leave or go get food and come back. I haven't had food since breakfast.
We all pile into the Why Don't We van. I sit in the back in between Jack and Corbyn. Jonah is driving. I'm playing on my phone not knowing what to talk about with the boys and Jonah is playing their new song. 'These girls'
Jack suddenly steals my phone and inputs his number in it and texts himself so he can have mine.
"Um excuse me Jack that's my phone." I said
"I know I just gave you my number and since your friends with Logan I put my name as something funny in your phone."
"Oh?"

I look in my messages and I see a conversation started that just says 'casey' the recipients name: Noodle hair Jack 🍜

Of course he would make that his name. Then I hear Jonah yell from the front.

"HEY! She likes us both we both deserve a fair shake give her my number to!"

"Fine man fine." Jack says taking my phone and putting Jonahs number in it as simply

Jonah Marais.

He doesn't give Jonah an emoji or anything. I'm guess Jack is more hopeful then anything.

After we get food we end up going back to My apartment. I sit on the couch and turn on a movie. I don't have cable yet. The boys and Logan sit down. Jack and Corbyn sit on either side of me. Corbyn took my phone and also put his number in it and being funny.
Corbean.

He then texts me and says.

Corbean: So Jack thinks you are beautiful so does Jonah BUT honestly I think you'd make a better couple with Jack. All the girls Love Jonah and it could get hectic and if your the jealous type at meet and greets sometimes the fans get handsy with him. I'd say go for Jack. So does my girlfriend Christina aka beautychickee.

Casey: Thanks Corbyn I'll think it over BUT I've only known you guys less then 12 hours.

Corbean: I know but I saw the look on your face and theirs when we meet you.

I just look at him and nod.

Today has been a weird day. I end up curling up on the couch and lay my head on Jacks shoulder and fall asleep.

***Jacks POV***

I look down when I feel something on my shoulder and Casey has laid her head on my shoulder and I gently lay mine on hers. Soon she's asleep and I hear Jonah whisper.
"What the hell man?!"
"Shhh! I'm just cuddling back"
Jonah rolls his eyes.

We finish the movie and I pick Casey up and go and lay her down on her bed. I turn to leave when I feel a tugging on my wrist.

"Stay with me Jack." Casey says sleepily

"Ok let me tell the boys and I'll be right back I promise."

"Ok."

I leave and walk back into Caseys living room.

"Guys Casey wants me to stay with her tonight. I'm gonna stay. Jonah don't start I see that look"

"Fine!" Jonah says

"Ok Jack. We will see you later" Corbyn says I walk the boys out of Casey's apartment along with Logan and I lock the door.
I walk quietly back to Casey's room take of my jeans and shirt and get under the covers with Casey I wrap my arms around her waist and slowly drift off to sleep. It's 11pm the earliest I've gone to bed in a while.