The Secret PT 2 || A Pretty Little Liars fanfic

Aria and Eli

Spencer, Hanna, Emily, Eli and I arrived back at Ezra's apartment shortly after the ceremony. I was terrified to be out there in the open with -A; With Ali, Watching us.
I changed Eli's diaper as the girls plugged their noses, I scoffed at them; It's just a baby doing its regular duty. Imagining them as parents is absurd considering they can't even stand the smell of a child's regular cycle, The most surprising part is I thought Hanna would get pregnant first out of all of us. I know that is wrong to say but it just seems more like a Hanna thing to do, Though she would be a great mother. They all would make great mothers with all their different traits, Hanna being an animated, Brave and light hearted would make for such a fun mother. Spencer with logical thinking, lovable presence and reasonable personality would make for such an understanding and well balanced mother. Then there is Emily, The rational and supportive but also peaceful friend who would make the most amazing mother in the world.


A fresh diaper change and Eli smells as fresh as ever, I place him on my lap as I give him his bottle. Making silly faces, Sticking out my tongue and making monkey noises to see that huge smile on his face. ''That couldn't have been Ali.'' Spencer finally spoke out, ''Are you sure it was Ali in the first place?'' Emily questioned me. I sighed, ''I know what I saw, Okay? It was Alison, In a black hoodie with a phone in her hand.'' My tone blunt, I knew this hurt Emily because of her feelings for Alison but I didn't know why Spencer was in denial. It all made sense, The one we trusted the most; The most deceitful of them all - Turned out to be our attacker. It's the ultimate trick, Pulling the wool over our eyes. ''God, I can't believe this. That bitch!'' Hanna exclaimed, Frustrated by our suppose to be best friend. I covered Eli's ears ''Hanna, Hello. Child in the room.'' I fumed, Angered that she swore in front of my son; Who I swore to myself I would not expose to the harsh world. Hanna held her hands up ''I'm sorry, It's just hard to believe.'' Hanna apologized as she chewed on her nails in a nervous fit.

Spencer paced around the room slowly, In deep thought like she usually was most of her days. ''We need to lure her out.'' Spencer said, Coming to a conclusion. Emily furrowed her brows with narrowed eyes as Hanna shook her head, Her blonde hair shaking in sync. I looked up at Spencer ''How?'' I simply questioned, If Alison is -A then she will always be one step ahead of us, Like she has been for the past two years. There is no way we can trick her or even lure her out.
''We use her own tricks against her.'' Spencer says as a devious smile crosses her face.




After planning for what seemed to be hours, We finally came up with a solid plan and then a back up plan so just in case the first one failed.
I was tired, The girls left for a party that involved the graduating class and their significant others. I missed out for obvious reasons, My pride and joy and the fact that my significant other was buried in the ground; Never to be seen again.
I huffed to myself, Out of boredom really. ''Come on Eli, Time for your bath.'' I smiled at him, Picking him up out of his playpen.

The bath was all ready for Eli, I held onto his arms as I sat him into the Luke warm water. Not like there was much water in there anyways, But I rather be safe then let him slip and hurt himself.
I poured small amounts of water over his head as he giggled with rosy red cheeks, ''Tilt your head back.'' I told him quietly as he did just as that, I washed his hair slowly and carefully; Making sure not to get any in his eyes.
''How is he?'' A voice came from behind me, My heart beat picked up and my motherly instincts kicked in as I held Eli closer to me. I looked behind me and sighed in relief ''You scared me! Don't do that!'' I protested, Almost peeing myself from being so scared. The person laughed, Kneeling beside me as they examined my son ''So beautiful.'' They mumbled as they stared at Eli. I nodded ''Just like his father.'' I almost breathed, Still feeling dead inside every time I had to relive the pain of losing Ezra.


I tucked Eli into his crib, He fell asleep in my arms but my arms were falling asleep so I thought it would be better for him to be in his crib.
This gave me and my visitor time to speak, I didn't think they'd be coming around; Ever again.
''You know you shouldn't be here, Or popping up every where.'' I told them, Not meaning to be rude but meaning to be truthful. They nodded and smiled ''I can't help it.'' They said, I understood.
''So Alison?'' They questioned me, I nodded twice; I don't know why but it seemed like a habit now. ''Playing all of us.'' I said slowly, Still surprised by the fact.  ''It's not a play, It's a show.'' Their tone was happy; Surprised. I smiled at them ''A great show.'' I commented.