Eyeless Jack X Reader (2) - Count me in

Cupcake making!

1 week later~

"Okay, this is harder than I thought it would be." Jane muttered as she sifted the flour and sugar in a bowl. You looked over at her and frowned.

"You're literally doing the easiest thing right now." You shook your head as you measured out gummy bears.

"Whatever." She sighed. "What's next?"

"Add the butter and the eggs and mix it all together." You stated, reading out the recipe.

"Yes, boss." You looked up at her and grinned. A question popped into your head and so you voiced it.

"Hey, have you ever baked before?" You asked her, adding one more gummy bear before smiling at the scale.

"Nope, I haven't really had the time," she looked over at you. "and no one's really able to bake except from you. Well, Masky and Hoodie can make a good cheesecake, but you know." You laughed and shook your head.

"Man, they are obsessed."

"Too true."Jane chuckled. "Finished!" She exclaimed in a sing-song voice. You bounced over to her and peered over her shoulder into the bowl.

"Okay, now let's add blue food colouring! Enough to match his mask." You smiled over at Jane, who picked up the food colouring.

"Ah, of course, the blue." She chuckled to herself, putting in a few drops of blue colouring ad mixing it to the right shade. 

"Good job!" You patted her head causing her to giggle and move away. "Now to add the secret ingredient!" You poured in the gummy bears and motioned for Jane to start mixing again.

"Ugh, really?" She looked at you, seemingly pleading.

"Hey, I'm teaching you how to make cupcakes. Be grateful." You glared at her.

"Uh huh, okay." She moved back to the bowl and started mixing again. You smiled at her and patted her back. "You are so annoying."

"You love me." You stated, matter-of-factly. Jane simply sighed.

~~~~~~~

The cupcakes were finally in the oven and so you headed to the living room with Jane for the 15 minutes you had to wait. You walked in to be greeted with E.J, Jeff, L.J and BEN playing Mario Kart, all sat on the main couch facing the TV.

"You boys are obsessed with that game." You sighed. Jane walked to the second couch, to the side of the TV and laid down on the couch. BEN looked up at you and glared.

"I'm not a boy, I'm a man!" He shouted before returning his attention to the game.

"You are literally a child." Jane stated, stretching her arms over her head. "My arms are still sore." She whined to herself, causing you to giggle.

"You guys suck, I'm literally older than both of you." He muttered. You laughed and Jeff joined in.

"You don't look it." He taunted, eyes remaining glued to screen.

"Jeff I will shove your entire ass down your fucking throat." BEN threatened, eyes turning red.

"Those are some big words for a kid." L.J laughed, BEN groaned.

"I'd like to see you try anyway. I will beat your ass." Jeff challenged.

"I hate you all." BEN muttered as he sunk back in his seat and pouted.

"Aww, I love you Ben." You walked over and patted his head.

"I love you too." He mumbled, his pout still present on his face.

"She loves me more though." E.J looked up from the game now that it had finished.

"That doesn't count, you're her boyfriend!" BEN whined.

"Damn right I am." He got up from the couch, walked over to you and wrapped his arms around your waist. "Hey babe." You giggled and wrapped your arms around his neck.

"Hey E.J." You lifted his mask a little to reveal his lips and kissed him. He returned the kiss, his tongue gently licking over your bottom lip.You smiled and opened up your mouth, slowly letting his tongue in. His tongue explored eagerly, not missing a single inch of your mouth. You moaned into the kiss, and then heard a groan from behind you.

"Get a fucking room!" Jeff yelled, throwing a cushion at the two of you. You pulled away from E.J and laughed.

"Sorry, I got a bit carried away." You scratched the back of your neck in embarrassment. E.J copied your action.

"Umm.. sorry. Who's up for another game?" He swiftly changed the subject. You smiled a little and shook your head whilst looking at the floor.

"I'm up for it." BEN shrugged, setting up the game and choosing his character. L.J shrugged, laughed and then also chose his character. Jeff frowned at the two of them.

"Am I really the only one who is concerned and grossed out about them making out right there?!"

"Eh, that's in the past." BEN looked intently at the screen and then at Jeff. "Are you going to choose a character?"

"Yeah, yeah." Jeff sighed. E.J laughed before sitting back on the couch and choosing his character. You giggled before walking over to Jeff, bending down and kissing him on the cheek. Slight colour spread across his cheek before he pouted.

"Hey, you're only allowed to kiss me on the cheek!" E.J whined. L.J laughed.

"Dude, she kisses everyone on the cheek." He added.

"Yeah, like, all the time." Jane spoke up, after having seemingly fallen asleep.The laughter of the group was interrupted by beeping. You clapped your hands together.

"Cupcakes!" You exclaimed in excitement. E.J looked at you and tilted his head to the side.

"Cupcakes?"He asked casually. Your eyes widened.

"What? No, no cupcakes." You hurriedly spoke. Jane sighed and shook her head.

"You're an idiot." She said before getting off the couch and walking to the kitchen, with you following close behind.

A/n- Finally a new chapter! I'm so sorry it's been so long, but I'm kinda back into things now so hopefully new chapters will come more frequently. I love you all, and as usual, have a good day/night!

~ Abyss