Eyeless Jack X Reader (2) - Count me in

Cupcake decorating and Card making

Back in the kitchen, Jane proceeded to watch you as you carefully took the cupcakes out of the oven and placed them onto the kitchen counter.

"They look amazing!" She yelled in wonder, leaning down to look at them closer. The dark blue cupcakes came out well, the colour really showing. You smiled at Jane's excitement.

"Come on, Jane, let's take them out of the tray." Jane nodded before helping you take the hot cupcakes out and place them on a tray to let them cool down quicker. 

"By the way," she looked over at you. "the cupcakes are hot. Be careful of your fingers." You looked at her, confused. 

" I know? Are you oka- oh." You grinned at her. "Did you burn your fingers?" You tried to stifle a laugh as she held her sore fingers in one hand.

"Shut up." She grumbled. You couldn't help but laugh out loud.

"Seriously, Jane, I just took them out of the oven. It's common sense to be careful." You continued laughing whilst taking the last few cupcakes out.

"I know, I just got carried away." She mumbled, a pout evident in her voice. You eventually stopped laughing, and instead simply smiled down at the cupcakes. 

"We did a good job!" You exclaimed, turning to Jane.

"Yeah, we did!" She answered, excitedly holding her hand up for a high-five. You high-fived her, just as excited as her, before the two of you turned back to the cupcakes. "What are we doing now?" She asked, turning to you and frowning at the grin forming on your face.

"You'll see." Was your answer, before you turned to grab things out of the fridge.

"This doesn't sound good." She sighed, before helping you.

~~~~~~~

"Cupcakes in the fridge, ready for tomorrow!" You exclaimed, bouncing up and down. Jane leaned her head against the table the two of you were sat at. 

"Wooh." Was her tired response. You on the other hand, had not time to be tired. Tomorrow was your 1 month anniversary! You had things to do! 

"Jane!" You shook her arm. "No time to sleep! We have a card to make!" You shook her again, causing her to groan.

"No, you have a card to make." She answered, not lifting her head from the table. You pouted at her.

"Rude." She didn't even acknowledge you this time. "Pfft, whatever. No time to deal with you." You turned and looked at the table covered with colourful paper, paint, crayons, pencils, pens, stencils, anything you could need to make your boyfriend a card! You smiled cheerfully before grabbing a piece of white card. This will be the base of the card. You quickly folded it into the shape of a card before grabbing a piece of dark blue card and doing the same to that. This will be the inside! You were quickly getting excited at the thought of giving the card to E.J. Man, he's going to love it! Well, at least I hope so... Oh, hush, yes he will. You quickly glued the inside (blue piece) to the base (white piece). Niiice. You then took a regular piece of white paper and drew your boyfriend, with his arms in the air out of excitement. You then cut this out and put it to the side. You then drew yourself, holding a kidney, your shirt lifted up to reveal your stitched up side. You giggled to yourself, causing Jane to finally lift her head up.

"Why are you laughing by yourself?" She asked, disgust and judgment evident in her voice. You simply showed her your drawing of yourself with the kidney. "Oh god." She then proceeded to slam her head back onto the table, causing you to laugh.

"Rude." You stopped laughing to continue the card. You glued E.J to the right side of the inside of the card, and then glued yourself to the left side of the inside of the card. You then closed the card and wrote in squiggly writing on the front 'I love you so much I'd...' and then you opened the card and wrote in squiggly writing on the left side of the card 'Give you my kidney' with a little heart for good measure. Under E.J you wrote ' Happy 1 month! I love you and look forward to many more months with you! Yours always, (Y/n)'. Proud, you shook Jane once more. She sighed and looked up.

"What?" You proceeded to shove the card in her face. She sighed again, loudly, before taking the card and reading it. You were worried about what her reaction would be, but only for a few seconds before she proceeded to laugh out loud. "Okay, I gotta hand it to you, this is pretty good. I'm actually really impressed." She continued to laugh as she handed you the card back. 

"Thank you!" You felt pretty good about the card before, but now even more so. "Okay, I've officially finished everything!" You stood up, quickly followed by Jane.

"Can we finally go to bed?!" She asked, excited at the thought, but her excitement quickly turned to disappointment when you shook your head.

"We have to clean this up first." You gestured to the mess of arts and crafts. Jane groaned.

"You're lucky I'm your friend." She grumbled before helping you clean up.

~~~~~~~

In your room, you had found a good hiding place for the card in your underwear drawer, where it would stay until tomorrow. You smiled at the thought of tomorrow, knowing it would be a truly beautiful day with the man that you loved. Smiling at the thought of Eyeless Jack, you grabbed your pyjamas and started getting changed when someone knocked on your door. 

"Uh, yes?" You answered a little hesitantly as you were standing in your room wearing only your (f/c) underwear and matching bra.

"Can I come in?" You quickly recognised the voice as that of your boyfriend. You smirked at the thought of him seeing you in what you were wearing, and before you knew it, you were unlocking your bedroom door for him. E.J stepped in quickly, closing the door behind him. "How was your-" His sentence was cut off as he turned around and noticed you. You blushed a little, but continued smiling at him in what you hoped was a seductive way. "(Y/n)." His voice sounded strained but he turned around and looked at the wall anyway. You moved towards him. 

"What's wrong, baby?" You asked, moving in front of him and wrapping your arms around his neck. He didn't look at you.

"(Y/n), I just want to make sure this is actually what you want." His voice had gotten considerably lower. He turned to look at you. "Do you want to do this?" He asked, his voice quiet. You bit your lip and nodded.

"If you want this, so do I." You answered, pressing your body against his. He breathed in sharply.

"Yeah." He nodded, wrapping his arms around your waist and leaning in. "This is definitely what I want." You giggled and reached up to remove his mask before leaning in quickly and kissing him. E.J shuddered against you, your fingers playing with his hair. He licked your bottom lip, asking for permission which you quickly granted. You moaned as his tongue travelled around your mouth, leaving no corner unexplored. E.J's hands roamed over your bare skin, squeezing and stroking everything he could. Being quite turned on by this point, you decided to quicken things up. You grinded against E.J, causing him to let out a loud moan. E.J's eye sockets locked onto your eyes before he pushed you onto the bed, landing just above you. He looked at you, once again asking for permission. You smiled up at him, pecked his lips and nodded. 

The two of you spent the rest of the night giving each other pleasure before finally succumbing to sleep. 

A/n- Hiya friends! I know I haven't been on here in a while, but I promised to finish this story and so finish this story I shall! Once this story is finished, I'll focus all my attention and energy on finishing my Jeff the Killer x Reader sequel! I hope you all enjoyed this part, if so, don't forget to comment and vote! I love you all, and as usual, have a good day/night!

~Abyss