True love male answers
Aquarius: Slender
Pieces: Masky
Aries: Toby
Taurus: Hoodie
Gemini: Laughing Jack
Cancer: Eyeless Jack
Leo: BEN DROWNED
Virgo: Glitchy Red
Libra: Lost Silver
Scorpio: Will Grossman
Sagittarius: Homicidal Liu
Capricorn: Jeff the killer