Broken (A Niall Horan Fan Fiction)

Chapter 3

Broken

*Lindsay's P.O.V.*

The door clicked and I stepped in. I was standing awkwardly in the doorway and I inhaled the stench of something burning. "I TOLD you not to try Zayn! I TOLD you!" Liam said as he shook his head and walked toward me. "Hey there love! My name is Liam!" "I'm Zayn," he said as he ran his fingers through his hair. "And...my name on my birth certificate is Jennifer," Louis said. "Hello Jennifer, my name is Stephanie," I replied, trying to mimic the voice Louis had been using. "What the fuck happened to my house?" Niall shouted when he inhaled the burnt air. "Zayn tried to make cookies. And they suck," a boy with chocolate brown curls and piercing green eyes said as he drank a glass of water, "I'm Harry by the way." "I'm Lindsay." I felt my heart flutter. Of all the boys in the band, besides Niall, Harry was my favorite. His eyes were a beautiful emerald green and his hair bounced when he walked. I'm pretty sure I had been staring at him for like a minute so I quickly said,"So you guys tried to make cookies?" The four boys that had been home lowered their heads and mumbled,"Yes.". I laughed and walked to the kitchen. I opened every cabinet; they were filled with chips and a bunch of other junk foods, but I sort of expected that because it was Niall's house. I pulled out 3 identical boxes. "Just so you know, my Kraft macaroni and cheese will defeat any other cook's any day," I said as I found a huge pot and turned the stove on. "It's true. I remember when we were 13, her Mac 'N Cheese came in second place," Niall said as he shoved a handful of chips in his mouth. "That's only because you went out and bought the fucking pie!" I said as I set the pot in the sink to fill it up with water. Harry came over and acted like he was intrigued by the water filling up the pot. "What happened to you arm?" Harry said after I turned off the water and set the pot on the stove. "Oh. I...um...I cut it," I replied like it wasn't what it really was. "You did? On what?" I looked at Niall, hoping he would do something to keep me from answering the question. He just kept shoving more and more chips in his mouth. "It's...from... um... I was doing a craft and I cut myself. On accident. Not on purpose." He looked into my eyes and somehow I knew that he knew the real reason. "So I'm ready for this amazing Mac n cheese!" Harry said as I took the pasta off the stove and poured the whole pot into a bowl. The boys ran and grabbed forks and started eating it out of the bowl. I rolled my eyes and got a fork as well. They all looked at me like I was some foreign species when I started eating out of the large bowl. "What did you expect? Me to go 'you guys are nasty'?" We kept eating and after a few minutes, all the pasta was gone. Niall went to the refrigerator and got out a pack of beers. Everyone but Liam grabbed a bottle and we passed around the bottle opener. "So. Shall we play truth or dare? It's never too early in my opinion!" Harry said as we all walked to the living room. "Sure! Just letting you know, I'm the best at this game," I said as I sat down on the couch next to Harry. I knew truth or dare was a dangerous game to play when there was only one girl but I didn't really care. "Okay Lindsay. Truth or Dare?" Louis asked me as he set down his beer bottle. "Dare." "Alright. I dare you to take off your shirt when Liam starts to freak out." I laughed. Liam looked pretty calm but I knew after a while he would freak out. "Harry, truth or dare?" I said as I turned towards the curly haired boy. "Truth." "If you could kiss Eleanor, Perrie, or Danielle, who would you kiss?" Liam started freaking out,"No. That's not fair. You can't ask that question!" "Lindsay. Shirt. Off. Now," Louis said as he pointed to me. I leaned forward and took my shirt off. The boys stared at me and I looked at Harry,"Answer the question Harold." "I would kiss, don't attack me Louis, I would kiss Eleanor." Louis stared at Harry and the curly haired boy looked at Niall. "I dare you to kiss Lindsay." "I was gonna say truth asshole!" "Just do it," Harry said. Niall leaned over and gave me a quick kiss. "Zayn, truth or dare?" Niall said after he sat back down in his seat. "Dare." "Why don't we just change this into dare or double dare? Everyone is doing dares anyways," I said. They all agreed and Niall gave Zayn his dare; Zayn had to draw "I'm a princess" on his forehead. "Dare or Double dare Liam?" Liam gave Zayn an 'are you crazy' look and Zayn dared Liam to stand on his head for a minute. 50 seconds into the dare, Liam crashed and his legs collided with the wall. I fell forward and Harry grabbed my arm to keep me from crashing into the table. He pulled me up and our eyes locked. "Louis. Dare or double dare?" "Double dare. And make it good this time. Last time all I had to do was tweet "I like spanking monkeys," I burst out in another fit of laugher. "I double dare you to change your Twitter bio to "I am a tetra-titted tossed" AND tweet a pic of you in your boxers." "You are no fun AT ALL Liam," Louis said as he took out his phone and pulled down his pants. After he finished the dare, Louis turned to me and asked me which I wanted. "Double dare," I responded with confidence. "I double dare you to take off your shorts and give Harry a lap dance," Louis said with a smirk. "No. That's intruding on Lindsay's-" "Niall, chill. It's okay. It's just a dare," I said as I unbuttoned my pants and slid them off. "Wait," I said before I sat down on Harry,"Everyone take your shirts off. I'm the only one with any article of clothing off. So shirts off." They all took their shirts off and Zayn plugged in his iPod and started the music. I heard a door slam and looked to see Niall wasn't in the room anymore. "Where the fuck did Niall go?" I asked as I got off Harry. "He went outside," Liam said. I slid my shirt on and pulled my pants up as I opened the door. "The fuck Niall?" he turned around and he looked angry but yet hurt at the same time. "What? I'm just supposed to sit there and watch as the girl I like gives my best friend a-a fucking lap dance?" Niall shouted as he took a step closer to me. "It was a fucking dare! See. This is why I never played with you and your other guys when we were younger. You always got upset when something like this happened!" I was so upset I ripped the bandage off my arm and threw it at him. "Harry?" I yelled through the open door. "Yes?" I heard him reply in a quiet voice. "Take me home. I'm tired of this bull shit." "Lindsay! Don't. I'm sorry it's just I've liked you for so long and-" I was so angry I slapped him on the face. "Niall. Do you know how long I liked you for? I finally gave up on trying to be your girl when you left for the X-Factor. But I'm sorry. I don't feel the same way anymore." Niall covered his now red cheek and walked toward me until his lips were inches away from mine. I could barely smell the beer that he had just drunken and his lips crashed onto mine. It felt so wrong but so right. Harry was still standing there and I remembered the flutter I had felt when I saw him. But now that flutter was because Niall was kissing me. He pulled away and said with a smile,"Let's finish that game."